Anthony Kenny (Master 1978–1989)
In his old age, Peter Geach would often say that Balliol had saved his immortal soul. He meant this literally. His father, a philosophy professor in the Indian Educational Service, was a man who constantly changed his religion. (When he was a schoolboy at Clifton College friends would greet Peter after the vacation with ‘Hello, Geach! Good hols? Does God exist this term?’) One of Geach père’s mystical experiments was devil-worship, of the style promoted by Alesteir Crowley, and he encouraged his teenage son to join him in this supernatural quest. Arriving at Balliol in 1934, Peter would later explain, cured him once and for all of any temptation to indulge in such pernicious nonsense. Whether or not this is true (and it must be confessed that as it got older, Peter’s memory became more and more creative), it is certain that Peter’s years as a Balliol undergraduate had a lifelong influence on his intellect and his character and left him with a passionate, indeed romantic, love for the College. His childhood had been unhappy: his father’s marriage to Eleonora Sgonina, the daughter of Polish emigrants, had broken up shortly after his birth, and when he was four years old he had been made a ward, forbidden to have contact with his mother. years at Llandaff Cathedral School and Clifton College left little mark: it was at Balliol that for the first time Peter found himself in congenial company.
Like many another Balliol man, he owed far more to his contemporaries than to his tutors. In 1991 he wrote, in a preface to a Festschrift, ‘Apart from the healthy immersion in Plato and Aristotle that I owe to my tutor, Donald Allan [Fellow 1931–1947], I owe far more to Balliol for the freedom of endless discussion with my peers than for any formal philosophical teaching. In retrospect I seem to have spent four years almost entirely in Balliol; I never went to philosophy lectures outside the College and knew hardly anybody in other Colleges.’
In Peter’s Balliol years, 1934–1938, there were certainly many interesting undergraduates to converse with. When he arrived, Jo Grimond (1932) and Stuart Hampshire (1933) were already in residence; George Malcolm (1934) and John Templeton (1934) were his exact contemporaries; and during his years in College Edward Heath (1935) and Denis Healey (1936, Honorary Fellow) arrived. In his last years Peter was one of the very few survivors of that fascinating pre-war generation.
It was in his final year, just before gaining a First in Greats, that Peter became a Roman Catholic. In his later memoirs, he attributes this above all to discussion with his Balliol contemporaries. ‘Increasingly, as time went on,’ he wrote of his Balliol years, ‘I found myself arguing with Catholics. I was certainly cleverer than they, but they had the immeasurable advantage that they were right – an advantage that they did not throw away by resorting to the bad philosophy and apologetics then sometimes taught in Catholic schools. One day my defences quite suddenly collapsed: I knew that if I were to remain an honest man I must seek instruction in the Catholic Religion.’
An event in Peter’s Balliol career that entered into College legend took place on 11 December 1936, the day of the abdication of Edward VIII. With the help of a Freshman history undergraduate, Hugh Fraser (1936), Peter raised a Jacobite flag above the Balliol tower and proclaimed the accession to the throne of the Stuart pretender, Rupprecht of Bavaria. Recording this event later, he explained that he had at the time, influenced by Hobbes, believed that it would be to the nation’s benefit to restore a strong monarchy.
No such thing could be hoped for, I thought, so long as the House of Windsor reigned; i judged them to be quite unfitted, by character, tradition, and training, to assume the role of Sovereign, instead of rubber-stamping Acts of Parliament. Only romantic folly made me ignore the question whether the family who would be de jure claimants if the Hanoverian usurpation were undone were at all likely to be better as Sovereigns.
When recording his Jacobite escapade in private, Peter would observe tartly that their joint venture had not prevented Sir Hugh Fraser (Secretary of State for Air 1962–1964) from ‘serving as Minister to the Guelph usurper’.
What did Balliol contribute to Geach’s later distinction as a philosopher? A great deal, but most of it negative. Peter detested the political philosophy that he was taught, which praised Locke and Rousseau and condemned Hobbes. In reaction, he condemned Locke as a time server and Rousseau as mad, bad, and dangerous to know. En revanche, he tells us, ‘I became convinced that Hobbes was a great and good man, who loved justice and mercy and the rule of law, and hated pride, arrogance, cruelty and other such vices of public life.’
Oxford by the likes of Cook Wilson and F C S Schiller, and he saw no reason, later in life, to revise that opinion. Only his reading of the Nicomachean Ethics with Donald Allan seems to have left a positive, lifelong influence. it was not until after leaving Balliol that he began the reading of Aquinas that exhibits itself prominently in much of his later work.
On Corpus Christi day in 1938, just after his success in Greats, Peter met his future wife, Elizabeth Anscombe. It was to be three years before they married, but from that moment they forged one of the most fruitful philosophical partnerships of the 20th century. The two philosophers are nowadays best known as heirs of Wittgenstein, but their independent talents predate their encounter with that philosophical genius. Peter, in his memoir, offers a moving description of the years between their engagement and their wedding.
Elizabeth had a lot of philosophical teaching from me. I could see that she was good at her subject, but her real development was to come only under the powerful stimulus of Wittgenstein’s lectures and her personal conversations with him. Naturally she then moved away from my tutelage; I am afraid that I resented that, but I could recognize this feeling as base and irrational, and soon overcame it.
Geach went on to become one of the dozen best British philosophers of the 20th century, and to become a master of English philosophical prose second only to Thomas Hobbes, John Henry Newman and Bertrand Russell. I hope elsewhere to do justice to his philosophical and literary achievements, but in this context it is only necessary to record his lifelong devotion to Balliol and his delight when elected to an Honorary Fellowship in 1979. I still recall the debate in Governing Body when he was proposed for election. There were those who were opposed: Geach was too much of a Catholic apologist, and there were other famous Balliol philosophers, X and y, who had a stronger claim. The issue was settled when an atheist philosophy Fellow growled, ‘Geach’s writings will still be read when X and y are names that everyone has forgotten.’
Geach did not forget his classical training at Balliol. In his sixties he wrote an autobiographical poem in elegiac couplets. It has not been published, and I much doubt whether it ever will be. But it contained two lines which, written when he was 69, and quoted at the funeral service after his death at the age of 98, are a wonderful summary of his serene old age:
Sexaginta annos complevi hucusque novemque,
In Domino sperans, dum vocet ipse: Veni.