Obituaries

This page honours and celebrates the lives of Old Members, academics, staff, and friends of Balliol. We hope it will provide a lasting and accessible record of those connected to the College, while also offering a space for reflection and remembrance of their achievements, contributions, friendships, and the many ways in which they shaped the life of Balliol and the wider world.

The obituaries currently available on this page have been drawn from previous editions of the Annual Record, as well as from publicly available obituaries published elsewhere online. This page is still in development, and we hope over time to build a more comprehensive record.

If you would like to submit an obituary of a Balliol member, please contact the Development Office at: development.​office@​balliol.​ox.​ac.​uk.

Professor Brian Warner

Henry Skynner Fellow 1965–1967
25 May 1939 — 05 May 2023

John Jones (1961, Fellow 1966–2009, Emeritus Fellow since 2009)

Brian WarnerBrian Warner was born near East Grinstead in Sussex on 25 May 1939. His parents were Leslie Warner, a gardener, and Edith Mary Bashford, who were married at East Grinstead in 1927: he was their only child. Somehow, he got into East Grinstead County Grammar School despite failing the Eleven Plus. While there he became seriously interested in astronomy and was encouraged by the eccentric amateur astronomer Patrick Moore. In Moore’s Guardian obituary (2012), he wrote: 

Having, as a schoolboy, lived within bicycling distance of Patrick’s house in East Grinstead, I benefited from his encouragement and generosity of time and, in deed, from his introduction to those who were later to become my teachers and mentors. And I still value the inscribed books he gave me during those years. 

After graduating with a BSc in Astronomy and a PhD in Astrophysics at UCL, Brian was awarded a Studentship to work at the Radcliffe Observatory in Pretoria, and while there he was elected to the Henry Skynner Fellowship at Balliol, designated as a Radcliffe-Henry Skynner Fellow because the Radcliffe Trust contributed to the cost. 

Henry Skynner (1816–1884) was a wealthy London solicitor who said he was ‘devoted to the science of astronomy’ in his will, which endowed Scholarships or Fellowships at Balliol to encourage ‘the study of the Science of Astronomy and of original research and discovery therein’. Skynner’s reason for choosing Balliol is obscure. He had no discernable connection and it is tempting to speculate that he knew of Balliol’s earlier associations with astronomers such as James Bradley FRS (1710), Astronomer Royal 1742. It was more likely a reflection of Benjamin Jowett’s reputation. He drafted the detailed regulations for the Trust set out in the will and was left ten guineas for a ring ‘as a small recognition of his valuable assistance to me in framing the preceding rules’. It was Balliol’s first endowment for any kind of research. ‘Mr Henry Skynner’s Trust (1879)’ continues as a separate Trust Fund, and the Henry Skynner Fellowship remains part of the College’s Early Career Fellowships programme. 

Brian was a gregarious, popular member of the Balliol SCR. I got to know him well then and we kept in touch until recently. After Balliol he spent five years at the University of Texas, and he might well have stayed there. But when Jack de Wet (1935, Fellow 1946–1970, Vice-Master 1970–1971, Emeritus Fellow 1971–1995) was appointed Dean of Science at the University of Capetown (UCT), he immediately recruited Brian to be the first Professor and Head of the new Department of Astronomy. UCT was Brian’s academic base for the rest of his life. He was prolific and original and built up his department from scratch to be world-class. I cannot add much to what can easily be found online about his contributions to astronomy and the many awards and honours showered upon him. But it is appropriate to mention here that he was awarded an Oxford DSc when he was only 47 for his early work on rapidly variable (i.e. flickering) stars; the judge’s report described his classic paper of 1974 as ‘a uniquely beautiful and seminal piece of work’, and him as ‘the leader in this field, pioneered by him’. 

He wrote hundreds of journal papers (some thirty before finishing his PhD) and several books between 1960 and 2022. His most important book was probably Cataclysmic Variable Stars (CUP 1995) but he also published scholarly volumes on the history of astronomy and botany in South Africa. His talents were diverse and surprising: a woodworking virtuoso, he once made a harpsichord, and he wrote humorous and irreverent verse. A major f igure in South African scientific and cultural affairs, he was a Trustee of the South African Library and also of the South African Museum (Chairman 1991 –1999). 

He died on 5 May 2023, survived by two former wives, two children, two grandchildren, and two great-grandchildren. 

There are a number of informative accounts of Brian Warner and his work online, including: Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Warner_(astronomer) Patrick Woudt: https://www.news.uct.ac.za/article/-2023-05-08-brian-warner-25-may-19395-may-2023 George Ellis: https://doi.org/10.17159/sajs.2023/16307 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I am grateful to Jo White of the Development Office for assistance; to Faye McLeod, College Archivist, for copying material from the College Archives, especially the will of Henry Skynner; and to Alice Millea of the University Archives for the DSc Report. The photograph is from the SCR Album.

Vicky Neale

Whitehead Lecturer in Mathematics from 2014 and Supernumerary Fellow from 2016
28 March 1984 — 03 May 2023

Derek E. Moulton (Fellow and Tutor in Mathematics) and Frances C. Kirwan (Emeritus Fellow)

Vicky NealeVictoria Neale, known to all of her colleagues and friends as Vicky, was born in Worcester on 28 March 1984, the first child of Barbara and Brian Neale. 

Education was an integral part of Vicky’s life from the very beginning. She was fascinated by mathematics from an early age, with activities such as counting the stairs on the way to bed providing an engaging way to explore numbers. Her love for learning expanded to encompass many subjects, and she soaked up knowledge wherever she could. Vicky’s intelligence stood out among her peers, as she effortlessly grasped concepts beyond her years. In primary school, classmates sought her help with unfamiliar words during reading lessons, her innate teaching abilities already starting to shine. 

At the age of seven, Vicky’s mathematical talent garnered attention, and she was assessed by the county’s ‘gifted children’ advisor. By the age of ten, she had started to delve into advanced mathematical concepts, teaching herself topics like Cartesian coordinates and simultaneous equations. Her passion for mathematics grew even stronger as she learned more. She was keen to participate in extra-curricular activities such as the UK Mathematics Trust’s ‘maths challenges’ in secondary school and beyond, persuading her sixth-form college to partake in competitions they had never been involved in before. Her friend Tim Austin, now the Regius Professor of Mathematics at the University of Warwick, recalls: 

Vicky and I were in the same school year, and we met as students at the various camps that followed the British Mathematical Olympiad. We quickly discovered a lot in common besides maths itself, and she was one of my closest friends by the time we started at Cambridge together. On a dusty shelf in my office, I still have photocopies of her immaculate handwritten notes from lectures that I missed. I can still recall the smell of ‘pasta and stuff’ filling her tiny college kitchen as we shared hopes, or worries, or stories about parents and siblings. 

Vicky was a talented mathematician and a gifted teacher. She was also a deeply good person: honest and straightforward, unfailingly generous, instinctively humble, uncompromising when called for. We shared a love for the subtle beauty of Nature’s more desolate places: I can still picture her knitting in a tiny youth hostel in the Hebrides, grinning broadly at the top of Skiddaw, or sharing her lunch on a seawall in Essex. We could usually find a sense of humour in common even when we disagreed. 

Vicky had the wonderful ability to immerse herself completely in a moment of the sublime, whether sitting in a lecture, listening to a joke, or reaching the rim of some windswept cliff. Perhaps the great joy of being a mathematician is the beauty of first contact with a new mathematical idea. But it always seemed that Vicky could recapture that sense of beauty, quite undiminished, whenever she revisited an idea later in her mathematical life. Then she could impart it to some one else with all the clarity and sparkle that she still saw it with herself. 

This love, combined with her unwavering curiosity and hunger for knowledge, led her to study mathematics as an undergraduate at Trinity College, Cambridge, where she became President of the Trinity Mathematical Society and ended three successful undergraduate years as Second Wrangler in 2005, afterwards continuing at Trinity to complete a Masters (Part III of the Mathematics Tripos). Vicky remained at Cambridge for her PhD, working under the supervision of Ben Green (now the Waynflete Professor of Pure Mathematics at Oxford). Her PhD, awarded in 2011, was in an area of pure mathematics called analytic number theory, concerning what is known as the Hardy–Littlewood circle method. 

During her tenure as a PhD student, Vicky joined Murray Edwards College in 2009 as a Bye-Fellow (a Fellow who does not take part in the government of the College), College Lecturer, and Director of Studies (DoS) in Maths where she made an indelible mark, taking on numerous roles and an active interest in teaching. 

Having been President of the Trinity Mathematical Society, Vicky brought with her an ambitious approach to mathematics that invigorated the students. Under Vicky’s guidance, they became more confident and adventurous, embracing the challenges and opportunities presented by the subject. She also made both Murray Edwards and mathematics an attractive destination. Owen Saxton, a Fellow in Physics at the time, recalls: ‘Where I had as DoS in Physics welcomed a steady stream of wonderfully able students changing from maths to physics over the years before her arrival, this stopped immediately and even reversed to the extent of a couple of my students opting to do the infamously challenging Part III Maths course after completing a physics BA.’ 

Vicky’s dedication to mathematics extended beyond the classroom. She published a weekly challenge question on the noticeboards, encouraging students to think critically and creatively. These challenges not only engaged the students but also showcased Vicky’s commitment to fostering a stimulating academic environment. 

As a Director of Studies, Vicky’s expertise and guidance helped shape the mathematical journeys of numerous individuals. Students were drawn to her supportive nature and her ability to challenge them to reach new heights of understanding and confidence. One of those students, Abi Royal, recalls: 

There wasn’t a single second where I ever doubted how completely she believed in me, even when I didn’t believe in myself. Vicky had so many idiosyncrasies that still make me smile when I think about them: her colourful trousers, her mathematical knitting, her bad maths puns and the way she would smile when she told them ... She was also an absolutely phenomenal teacher – I was lucky enough to be supervised by her a fair few times, as well as attending her third year Number Theory lectures. Her ability to communicate complex ideas in such an understandable and charismatic way was absolutely unparalleled. 

Collaborating on admissions interviews, Vicky displayed her discerning insight and an unwavering commitment to fairness. She was known for challenging traditional approaches to questioning, favouring enquiries that assessed candidates’ problem-solving skills and ability to navigate the unknown. 

While Vicky was an undergraduate, she had volunteered with AskNRICH, an online forum set up by the NRICH Project in Cambridge. School students could seek help and advice with maths and maths-related issues. Vicky spent a few weeks during the summer holidays working for NRICH, writing articles for school students and editing resources. Her love for the subject and her passion for communicating it shone through, to the extent that when the AskNRICH Coordinator went on maternity leave, Vicky stepped into the role with ease. When she became Director of Studies at Murray Edwards, she continued to collaborate with NRICH, helping to organise maths events for local children and their families on Saturday mornings. 

Recognised as an exceptional role model for young mathematicians, Vicky was often asked to represent the Cambridge Mathematics Faculty at Open Days for prospective undergraduates. Her belief that mathematics could be enjoyed and appreciated by all students made her the perfect candidate to take a leading role in the Cambridge Mathematics Education Project (CMEP, later known as Underground Mathematics) for sixth-form students. She was recruited alongside Steve Hewson from NRICH to lead the development of this very open-ended DfE-funded project – how best to realise the aim of improving the teaching of A-Level Mathematics was not at all clear. CMEP Director Professor Martin Hyland recalls the start. of the project. 

Vicky Neale at Murray Edwards College. Vicky and Steve introduced a way to describe progress through A-Level in terms of a Tube Map: stations displayed teaching resources devoted to the key topics. The nature of the resources was critical. They were to be Low Threshold High Ceiling, in the terminology of NRICH, and suitable for group work in class. Less palpable was the philosophy established by Vicky and Steve with the firm idea, stemming from their joint experience in NRICH, that authority lies in the mathematics. The overall tone, established early, lasted through the whole project. 

In summer 2013, the project was committed to holding two Summer Workshops to obtain initial feedback from teachers. Sadly by then Steve had become very ill. Though others pitched in to help, Vicky was responsible for the planning, and she ended up fronting the majority of the sessions. Both intellectually and physically it was an amazing feat. One workshop outcome proved very special. The project needed to showcase teaching materials. Vicky had the idea for a circle-sorting resource. This was wonderfully realised by Karen Habermann, a student working with the project. Search the web for ‘Teddy Bear, Circle’ and you will find what became the exemplary resource for Underground Maths. 

While at Murray Edwards, Vicky also succeeded in persuading (in the way that only Vicky could) the college, the Cambridge Faculty of Mathematics and the United Kingdom Mathematics Trust to set up the European Girls’ Mathematical Olympiad (EGMO) and host the inaugural event in 2012. The year after this event she described EGMO as follows, modestly omitting her own huge contribution (together with that of Ceri Fiddes, Julia Gog and others) to its existence and success. 

The aim is to encourage more girls to participate in mathematics competitions, as a way of getting more girls involved with mathematics more generally. The format is rather similar to many other international mathematics competitions, such as the IMO, and like these the host country will change each year. The papers at EGMO provided challenging mathematics, and the students also enjoyed the social aspect of the programme. Sixteen European countries sent teams, along with three guest nations. Following the success of EGMO in 2012, the second EGMO has recently happened in Luxembourg, and EGMO will be held in Turkey in 2014. 

Ceri Fiddes, Assistant Head, Teaching and Learning, at Millfield Senior School, recalls: 

Vicky and I worked closely on this project and she was a superb partner in every way. Her passion, drive and high level of organisation made everything easy and enjoyable. The mathematical craft evening was a particular highlight and a very typical Vicky event. Teams from 20 countries spent the evening curve stitching and making incredible origami polygons (followed by a ceilidh). She thought it was hilarious that I had budgeted £100 for the event when in reality she had just planned to bring in her own collection of embroidery threads and coloured paper. 

Vicky’s ability to persuade others to help her to get things done was remarkable. Thomas Forster, then a lecturer in the Department of Pure Mathematics and Mathematical Statistics (DPMMS) at Cambridge, remembers: ‘She had a rare talent for getting people to do things that they really didn’t want to do, and to achieve it without actually annoying them.’ 

Another Cambridge colleague, Marj Batchelor, remembers Vicky warmly as 

one who had a rough sea to sail and held her course to her great credit and honour. The department was then very focused on its research image; it was a brave young mathematician who would invest time, energy and enthusiasm in teaching and communicating mathematics to more general audiences ... In doing so per haps she showed us a better way of being mathematicians, her simple humanity reconciling those perceived polarities, research and teaching. 

Julia Gog, Professor of Mathematical Biology at Cambridge, loved working with Vicky, particularly on the 2012 EGMO Committee, and in the Faculty of Mathematics, where 

Vicky brought much thought and wisdom to many issues we were grappling with then and now. For example: how do we encourage the strongest potential maths students to apply to top universities, no matter who they are and their background, how do we deliver our lectures and teaching so that students can best learn, and how do we shape our degree and examine fairly? Vicky never shied away from challenging questions, and made important contributions on all of these. … Even now around ten years on, I can see so many places where Vicky’s influence has changed how we do things, and always for the better for our students.

Vicky remained at Murray Edwards until 2014 as a Senior Teaching Associate, before accepting the position of Whitehead Lecturer at Oxford’s Mathematical Institute and Balliol College (where she later became a Supernumerary Fellow). This position was not a typical one, but rather had been specially constructed for someone with Vicky’s rare attributes in mind: while the role had the usual teaching responsibilities in department and college, instead of research the focus was on outreach and public engagement, both expanding existing initiatives and developing new directions to attract and inspire the next generation of mathematicians. 

A very large part of the role involved setting up the new European version (PROMYS Europe), based in Oxford, of the Boston-based PROMYS high school programme, and becoming PROMYS Europe’s Executive Director. It also included many other activities, such as giving public lectures, visiting schools and sixth-form colleges to give talks and lead workshops, lecturing at Oxford’s UNIQ Summer Schools, and supporting UK mathematics in general, for example via involvement with the London Mathematical Society’s Education Committee and giving Royal Institution Mathematics Masterclasses. 

Vicky was the driving force and inspiration behind the ‘It all adds up: celebrating women across the mathematical sciences’ events for schoolgirls, which have happened each year in Oxford’s Mathematical Institute since 2016. The first such event was part of the London Mathematical Society’s 150th Anniversary celebrations in 2016; afterwards Stephen Huggett (then the LMS General Secretary) described it as ‘a spectacular event’ in the Newsletter of the European Mathematical Society: ‘The first two days were devoted to mathematically inclined schoolgirls, while the second two days were for female mathematicians at all stages of their university careers. There were talks, discussions, workshops, and poster displays. It was a huge success.’ 

Vicky did extensive work with the United Kingdom Mathematics Trust (UKMT). She had been a UKMT volunteer for many years, after participating as a teenager in numerous UKMT activities and being selected herself for the IMO training squad. She was heavily involved with the UKMT mentoring scheme, and with the setting up of the UKMT’s Enrichment Subtrust (acting as its first Chair). She was also a member of the British Mathematical Olympiad Subtrust for a long time, and helped with running summer schools and maths circles, later joining the UKMT’s Council/Board of Trustees. 

Vicky also became increasingly involved with the London Mathematical Society. She gave an LMS Popular Lecture on ‘Addictive Number Theory’ in 2013, and was a Holgate Lecturer. Later she became a member of the Education Committee of the LMS, and a regular contributor to the LMS Newsletter and member of its Editorial Board. 

It was clear from the beginning that Vicky was the perfect fit for the Whitehead Lecturer role, and conversely, she had found her ‘dream job’. There was something unique in Vicky, something genuine in her approach to even the smallest task, that was almost hard to define. In the words of Dyrol Lumbard, External Relations Manager at the Mathematical Institute, who would work closely with Vicky on a number of projects over the years, 

Yes, she was energetic, very clever, certainly very kind, but what I came to most appreciate, and envy, was her selfless love of her subject and the people, especially her students, with whom she could share that love. Because in the competitive world of maths popularisers, Vicky wasn’t about Vicky. Vicky was about the maths. Not that she didn’t have opinions or didn’t express them, but they came with this obvious sincerity. 

Her commitment to inspiring school students to do mathematics and her advocacy for women and minorities in mathematics paved the way for a more inclusive and diverse mathematical community. But Vicky’s commitment to mathematics extended far beyond the confines of academia. Her passion for sharing the beauty and significance of mathematics with a broader audience was evident in books, online lectures, podcasts, YouTube videos, and media appearances, which made mathematics accessible and engaging to the wider public, fostering a newfound appreciation for the subject. 

Vicky wrote two influential books. Closing the Gap: The Quest to Understand Prime Numbers (Oxford University Press, 2017) delved into the intricate world of prime numbers, providing readers with a captivating exploration of this fundamental mathematical concept and progress towards proving the famous Twin Primes Conjecture. The book exemplified Vicky’s ability to communicate complex ideas in a way that engaged both experts and those new to the subject. Why Study Mathematics? (London Publishing Partnership, 2020) – a work that emphasised the relevance and practicality of mathematics in various fields of study and everyday life – inspired readers to appreciate the subject’s universal applicability, and it has undoubtedly encouraged numerous school students to choose mathematics as their path of study. 

Vicky’s expertise as a mathematics educator and her ability to articulate complex concepts made her a sought-after guest on several BBC radio programmes. Among her appearances, many of which may still be found online, are the following: 

• ‘Fermat’s Last Theorem’, In Our Time, BBC Radio 4 

• ‘Numbers Numbers Everywhere’, Series 10, The Infinite Monkey Cage, BBC Radio 4 

• ‘e’, In Our Time, BBC Radio 4 • ‘Vicky Neale on the Mathematics of Beauty’, A History of Ideas, BBC Radio 4 

• ‘Maths: Alex Bellos, Neil deGrasse Tyson, Serafina Cuomo, Vicky Neale’, Free Thinking, BBC Radio 3. 

Sharing her deep understanding of mathematics with the general public, sparking curiosity and enthusiasm in listeners, Vicky brought mathematics to life, bridging the gap between academic research and everyday experiences. 

In addition to her radio appearances, Vicky wrote for prestigious platforms such as The Conversation and The Guardian, engaging readers with thought provoking articles on mathematics-related topics. Her accessible writing style and knack for breaking down complex concepts into digestible pieces resonated with readers, making mathematics more approachable and captivating for a wider audience. 

When she died Vicky was President-Elect of the Mathematical Association, which exists ‘to support and promote confidence and enjoyment in mathematics for all’. She was also a Trustee of Mathematics Education for Social Mobility and Excellence (MESME).

 Hannah Fry, Professor in the Mathematics of Cities at University College London, describes her impact on the communication of mathematics during an interview for BBC Radio 4’s Last Word: 

[I] was just blown away by her grace of communication, but also her real commitment to trying to make our subject come alive for younger minds ... I would be gobsmacked if there weren’t literally hundreds, if not thousands, of people up and down the country who are studying mathematics and have become mathematicians as a direct result of the work that she did. I think that she, and I, believed really to our core that having a society that appreciates mathematics and has a good foundation in the mathematical sciences is better for everybody, and I think that there are few people in this country who had more of an impact on that goal than her.

In March 2021, Vicky was diagnosed with a rare form of cancer. While it would have been natural to withdraw from work, Vicky strived not to let the turn of misfortune deter her from mathematics and education, the things she loved most. In her final two years, she continued to teach as much as she was physically capable, and maintained a strong connection with the ongoings of both Balliol and the Mathematical Institute. She also didn’t hide from her diagnosis; rather she did with cancer what she had been doing throughout her life: learn and educate. Vicky used her own predicament as a catalyst to develop a podcast series called Maths + Cancer, in which she explored the use of mathematics and statistics in cancer research through a series of interviews with different experts. In 2023, the series was awarded a CASE Circle of Excellence Award, a silver medal in the podcasts category. 

Philip Maini (1979), Professor of Mathematical Biology at Oxford, was one of the researchers interviewed by Vicky for the podcast. Philip recalls: 

I find any form of public speaking (lecturing etc) to be stressful, particularly if it is being recorded. However, Vicky immediately put me at ease with her engaging manner. She knew all the appropriate things to discuss, and did so in a manner that brought out the best in me, another sign of a brilliant teacher. 

Chatting with Vicky during the podcast, it was easy to forget that she was actually suffering from this disease, and I am still in awe of the strength shown by Vicky in that, having been diagnosed with cancer, she decided to tackle under standing the disease head on and do a podcast that would help other people. 

In the realm of teaching, Vicky was one of a kind. In every teaching role she encountered, from lecturing at the Mathematical Institute to tutorial teaching at Balliol, lecturing at PROMYS Europe and her previous roles at Cambridge, her dedication to teaching was unparalleled. Her colleague Heather Harrington noted: 

Vicky possessed a remarkable ability to meet a student or class where they were at in terms of level and skill, and educate and inspire them to grow mathematically. About ten years ago, Vicky gave the LMS Popular Lectures, and I remember thinking, how can I possibly captivate such an audience in the same way? She motivated all of us to strive to be the best versions of ourselves. 

Vicky had an innate ability to engage students and explain difficult topics, both through immaculate and clear lecture notes provided online and through her lectures at the board, which often famously would be delivered without even holding any notes in hand. Some of these lectures were recorded and uploaded to YouTube, where they have been immensely popular – a lecture on the first-year undergraduate course ‘Introduction to Complex Numbers’ has garnered, at the time of writing, 2.3 million views. 

In the smaller setting of tutorials at Balliol, Vicky would use her imagination, inventiveness and infectious love of mathematics to engage students in a unique way. As an example, she frequently created overlaps between mathematics and her lifelong passion of knitting, be it a knitted scarf to illustrate the properties of prime numbers, a knitted octopus born of a discussion on base 8 that became a sort of mascot for Balliol mathematics, or little crocheted hedgehogs that would appear alongside truffles on the large desk in her Balliol teaching office. 

Vicky took a deep interest in her students’ general well-being. She frequently sacrificed her time well beyond the normal ‘stint’ to help students find their way. She introduced weekly walks following office hours, a chance for anyone who wished to join her as she traversed the city, engaging in casual chat about her cats, gardening, or any topic that came up, with no insistence at all that mathematics be discussed. 

While Vicky strived to make mathematics engaging and fun, she was also very demanding of her students, never letting a student off the hook after an unclear explanation. She insisted upon precision and rigour in written work, whether the exercise counted for anything official or not, and worked particularly hard with first-year undergraduates to frame their work within a structure of clearly stated Claims and Proofs (indeed so much so that many of them found it hard to avoid using this structure in more applied mathematics topics in which it was neither needed nor particularly appropriate). Vicky was deeply interested in teaching as a form that can be continually examined and improved. Nicola Trott (Senior Tutor), recalls: ‘Vicky was never less than whole-hearted: she gave unstintingly not only to teaching but also to the theory and practice of learning. She and another Balliol tutor set up a College forum for discussing and exploring different ideas and approaches – which, among other things, helped many get through the Covid years.’ 

Evidence for Vicky’s enormous success in teaching is given by her many teaching awards, beginning in 2015 with the award for Most Acclaimed Lecturer in Oxford’s Mathematical, Physical and Life Sciences Division in the student led OUSU Teaching Awards. In 2020, she completed the Oxford Postgraduate Certificate (PGCert) in Teaching and Learning in Higher Education, with Distinction, and received a PGCert Prize for the portfolio with the highest grade in her cohort in that year’s Vice Chancellor’s Education Awards, while in 2021 she was awarded Senior Fellowship of the Higher Education Academy (SFHEA) through the Oxford Teaching Recognition Scheme. 

Another telling measure of how effective she was in the classroom was the outpouring of memories from students past and present upon the news of her death. A webpage set up by the Mathematical Institute at Oxford contains dozens of fond recollections, including the following: 

Auri Guarino (2020): 

I found Vicky a real inspiration in school. Her online lectures and open day talks made maths seem so exciting and accessible, a feeling that I was not able to get from school. This motivated me to apply to Balliol and, after a (really quite fun) interview with Vicky where we discussed a problem involving bugs of different colours colliding, I was very fortunate to be accepted to Balliol. Vicky was a brilliant tutor – the benchmark for what an educator should be. She made every problem clear and accessible, and had a remarkable knack for figuring out what exactly was the core of my confusion and clearing it up. She was always on hand to receive questions outside of tutorials (whether through emails or office hours) and went far out of her way to answer them (including giving extra problems, hints, and offering one-on-one calls to clear things up if needed). I must add that Vicky was also an incredibly kind and thoughtful person who really cared about her students. Vicky’s enthusiasm, love for maths and education, and her calm and kind nature continue to inspire me today. 

Otilia Casuneanu (2021): 

Vicky was a true inspiration as a lecturer and as a tutor. Her dedication to teaching and mathematics changed the course of life for better for so many people, among which I am lucky to be. As a student at Balliol, the Vicky walk was one of my favourite moments of the week as Vicky would manage to lift up my spirits even in the most stressful times. Her energy and general good spirits were so contagious. 

The sentiments above shed some light on how important Vicky was to so many young lives, though this small sample cannot do justice to the huge impact she had. Her legacy was summarised for us by Hannah Fry: 

Vicky had an abundance of rare qualities, but for me there is one that stands out. She did things, not because they made her look good, but because she thought they were important. All those radio slots and books and outreach programmes, she did them because she knew they made a difference. They did, too. I can’t imagine the number of peoples’ lives she touched with her work. And she was so good at it. She had a commanding calmness to her. A warmth and twinkle that is so impossible to replicate, no matter how hard I try. I admired her enormously. And I really, honestly believe, the world was a better place with her in it.

Vicky Neale’s absence leaves an unfillable void in our hearts and minds. Her exceptional intellect, compassionate friendship, and transformative influence on communicating mathematics will forever echo not just within the departments and colleges that had the fortune to know her personally, but far beyond. Her books, radio appearances, writing contributions, and involvement in educational programmes and Olympiads all serve as testaments to her commitment to inspiring others and making mathematics accessible to all. Vicky’s outreach efforts have left an indelible impact on countless individuals, igniting a passion for mathematics and empowering aspiring mathematicians to pursue their dreams. We mourn the loss of a remarkable individual, yet we find solace in the profound impact she had on our lives and the enduring legacy she leaves behind. 

This is an edited version of an obituary published by the London Mathematical Society, reproduced by kind permission. The full obituary will be available at https://www.lms.ac.uk/publications/obituaries. 

Acknowledgements 

We thank Charlie Gilderdale, Ben Green, Jennifer Balakrishnan, Cora Cartis, Jason Lotay, and Vicky’s parents Barbara and Brian Neale for their help in writing this obituary. We are also very grateful to all the people who provided us with memories of Vicky, many of which were included as direct quotes, and all of which contributed to painting in our minds the picture of Vicky – dedicated educator, compassionate communicator of mathematics, and dear friend – that we have tried to get across in this obituary.

 

William Newton-Smith

1967, Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy 1970–2005, Senior Tutor 1978–1981, Praefectus of Holywell Manor 1989–1997, Senior Proctor 1984–1985 and Emeritus Fellow from 2005
25 May 1943 — 08 April 2023

Professor Steven Lukes (Emeritus Fellow) 

William Newton-SmithBill Newton-Smith, Fellow and Tutor in Philosophy from 1970 to 2005, tackled large questions with rigour and precision. He published six books, most notably The Structure of Time (1980) (Is time absolute or relative? Is it a container of events or composed of them? He rejected both views and advanced instead two new theories, so as to shift the argument to whether time is a theoretical structure or a theoretical framework) and The Rationality of Science (1981) (How, as ‘moderate realists’, are we to account for scientific progress? He here advanced a widened view of rationality that effectively answers the criticisms of such sceptics as Thomas Kuhn and Paul Feyerabend). He also published an introduction to logic, he edited the Blackwell Companion to the Philosophy of Science (2000), containing entries by many distinguished contributors and described by one reviewer as ‘delightful and clear’, and he co-edited Modelling the Mind (1990), a book on the central question of cognitive science: ‘how do we model the mind?’, deriving from a Balliol-based interdisciplinary seminar, bringing together a distinguished group of philosophers, psychologists, and physiologists. He also edited Popper in China (1992), a collection of previously unpublished essays from both the West and China on Karl Popper’s philosophy of science, arguing that Popper’s philosophy had a direct relevance to the wider political context in China. 

Bill was Senior Tutor from 1978 to 1981, but his presence, for the first two decades of his time at Balliol, was always felt around the College, from the seminar room to the squash court, from the SCR to Holywell Manor, of which he was Praefectus from 1989 to 1997. (He was also an effective Senior Proctor for the University in 1984–1985.) He was a much-loved and inspiring teacher of graduates and of undergraduates, remembered by one for his ‘humour and wise thoughts’ and for ‘taking the fear out of logic teaching’. Another writes that he ‘made me feel confident that I could, eventually, make some sense of Russell and Wittgenstein’. He was always fun to be with: Andrew Graham (Master 2001 2011) recalls that when acting as Bursar while Bill was Senior Tutor, ‘I have never had such a good time, certainly not in the administrative field.’ His enthusiasm was infectious. 

I loved co-teaching with him, as did other colleagues in different disciplines. I myself learned a great deal in discussions with him – for example, about whether theories can be underdetermined by all actual and possible observations (on which topic he published an article in the Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society in 1978), and about how to think about truth and rationality in relation to ongoing debates in which I was engaged at the time concerning the social sciences, particularly social anthropology, focused on how to understand and explain apparently irrational beliefs. He was thoroughly engaged in these discussions and in others that crossed over into the disciplines of our colleagues, including the scientists. For example, he participated in a series of seminars held in Balliol during the 1980s on the explanation of animal and human behaviour that led to the volume on modelling the mind, which arose from a long-standing collaboration between the philosopher Alan Montefiore (Emeritus Fellow) and the physiologist Denis Noble (Emeritus Fellow). Bill was a key member of our unusually cohesive PPE tutorial team. 

Yet his impact on the world was to reach very far beyond the readers of his philosophical writings and the walls of Balliol. In 1979 I drew his attention to a report in the Times Higher Educational Supplement of an open letter sent from Prague in the wake of the Charter 77 Petition by an unknown Czech philosopher of indomitable courage and tenacity, Julius Tomin, to four universities: Harvard, Oxford, Cambridge and the Freie Universität Berlin. The letter invited them to send philosophers to join him in teaching philosophy in his flat after the Czech regime’s recent drastic purge of universities. Only Oxford responded and that was because of Bill. He convinced the Philosophy Subfaculty to send philosophers to Czechoslovakia to lecture informal groups in private homes, together with small sums to cover their costs, and a network of such underground seminars soon developed to receive them. For the next eight years there ensued a stream of visiting philosophers from Oxford and beyond, including our colleague Alan Montefiore, Roger Scruton, Thomas Nagel, Charles Taylor (1952), Jacques Derrida and Jürgen Habermas, to address underground seminars, supporting dismissed Czech philosophers and their students, often smuggling books in and samizdat out. This clandestine international network was soon organised by the Jan Hus Foundation, of which Bill was a founding trustee. It was regarded as a ‘centre of ideological subversion’ by the Czech police. It financed the visits and helped in many other ways, such as supplying photocopiers behind the Iron Curtain. 

As one of the visitors in 1980, Bill had begun to address a gathering of some twenty students on the logic of science in Tomin’s flat when the doorbell rang, a dozen uniformed policemen entered to check identity documents, and he was arrested by two of them in plain clothes, taken away and interrogated for two hours. They ‘repeatedly tried to get me to say false things about Julius’, he recalled. His last sight of Tomin was of him being manhandled with blood on his face. Bill was then driven to the snow-covered border with West Germany. The Russian car broke down on the way and Bill helped to fix it, and at one point they lost their way and had to ask for directions. 

Other visiting philosophers were detained and deported, including Derrida, and a diplomatic incident was then averted by the intervention of the French President, François Mitterand. Other early visitors to be expelled included Kathy Wilkes and Anthony Kenny (Master 1978–1989). Tomin was employed as a zookeeper and his wife Zdena was one of the three spokespeople of Charter 77. Policemen were regularly stationed outside their apartment. Other former philosophy teachers and intellectuals in Prague, including the former Rector of Charles University, were stoking boilers in the basements of buildings and driving trams. They were under constant surveillance, as were their children at school, who were sometimes barred from further education, and they were subject to regular harassment, detention and interrogation by the security police. Most laid low, holding clandestine seminars; some collaborated and some, like Julius Tomin, actively resisted. The story of these visits is told in Barbara Day’s The Velvet Philosophers (1999). 

Bill’s lifelong concern for intellectual freedom probably originated when, while an undergraduate studying mathematics at Queen’s University in Ontario, Canada, he travelled to East Germany as part of a United Nations exchange programme to encourage mutual understanding among young people on both sides of the Iron Curtain. He had an East German penfriend whom he visited at Zittau in 1964, and he was deeply shocked by the barbed wire and minefields at the border and by what he learned about the activities of the Volkspolizei. The enduring impact of that visit led to the next stage of his academic activism in Eastern Europe and beyond. 

This began when Bill encountered George Soros, the billionaire Hungarian born financier and philanthropist (and the continuing target these days of antisemitic rhetoric in the ascendant right-wing politics in Eastern Europe, especially Hungary). Soros had been financing the Jan Hus Foundation and identified Bill as the person who could take a lead in his educational initiatives in Eastern Europe, which eventually came under the aegis of his Open Society Institute (later Open Society Foundations). Bill invited Soros to give a talk in Balliol about the theory of reflexivity in financial markets in the old Senior Common Room, and I recall a lunch at which the discussion was about Popper’s ideas, about which Soros had submitted a thesis at the LSE, and over which Bill and Soros disagreed. A Karl Popper Open Society award would become one of the initiatives set up later. But the major such initiative was the foundation of the Central European University (CEU), in which Bill played a critical role. 

The vision of this grand project had been born and nurtured in what seemed like purely idealistic discussions at the Dubrovnik Inter-University Centre, one of the few meeting places for students and faculty from East and West, in whose life Bill played an important role. Bill had also been instrumental in bringing East and Central European students on scholarships to Oxford. What made his role in establishing the CEU critical, according to Shalini Randeria, its current Rector, was that he overcame Soros’s uncertainties, strengthening his will to realise that vision. Bill then promptly went on to make it real. He later wrote to a former student: ‘From 1990 I was running George Soros’s higher education philanthropy including creating for him the Central European University of which I was the first rector president. Eventually juggling this activity with teaching at Balliol became a little tiresome and so I resigned a few years early to work full time with him.’ The juggling amounted, in effect, to his simultaneously leading two lives, applying to successive Masters for brief periods away. 

On Soros’s invitation, Bill became the chair of the Executive Committee – the predecessor of the Board – of the CEU, which laid down the foundations of the university. He was thus the de facto head of the institution until Alfred Stepan (1958) became the first de jure Rector in 1993. He then served as a CEU trustee between 1995 and 2016. As chair he brought all his well-honed Oxford intellectual and energetic skills to chairing, successfully, what was a wide-ranging board marching at high speed into the unknown, to the tune of Soros. It was, indeed, a Balliol-honed project, with Paul Flather (1973), a former student of Bill’s at Balliol, appointed by Soros in 1990, serving as the first CEO (secretary-general). Flather vividly describes Bill in this role: 

His mind was always working. Even when, after particularly successful CEU Executive Board and Senate meetings, the reward was a meal out in a rather fancy Parisian restaurant, over the courses we would be jotting notes on napkins. Many board meetings under the famous sloping beam of Holywell Manor would start at lunchtime, but not finish until well after midnight, with refreshments magically appearing at regular intervals, Bill, cigar in hand, and George striding about, with me desperately trying to keep up with the notes, admired however late, however stressed, there he was, full of beans, rarin’ to go, the next morning. 

After the fall of communism, it was a time of optimism about and within the region, an optimism that is now increasingly hard to sustain. The idea of the CEU was that of an independent international university for the wider region that would educate a new cadre of leaders to help to develop democratic practices and institutions after the fall of the Iron Curtain. Soros backed this mission with a cheque for many millions of dollars, and with pressure. Appointing Bill in 1991 he told him: ‘I want students here in September.’ Bill used all his contacts to find visiting tutors and students, and with the crucial help of Flather, materials and a set of buildings were acquired. The deadline was met and the university opened in the autumn of 1991. Bill had the extraordinary privilege of spending these millions of dollars –sometimes $200 million a year – promoting academic freedom, scholarship and community. He was trusted throughout and licensed to spend regularly in six and sometimes more figures. His time and energies were spent in engaging with distinguished scholars, and setting salary levels, choosing institutions to be supported, launching new institutions, such as the European University in St Petersburg, and pushing forward new programmes, such as the university libraries initiative, research support programmes and the CEU Press. 

Later it was Bill who helped to calm matters after Soros had fallen out with Václav Klaus, the new premier of Czechoslovakia, who said he would close the CEU at once, moving it to Budapest. It took time to persuade him that no university with hundreds of students could close overnight, and a delay of 18 months was secured. The CEU was originally located in three cities – Warsaw, Prague and Budapest. After the Czech and Polish campuses were closed down, it continued and flourished in Budapest, soon securing international recognition, attracting outstanding faculty and some 1,500 students from over 100 countries. However, in the wake of similar hostility to that of Klaus on the part of the autocratic Hungarian premier Viktor Orbán (who had studied at Pembroke College, Oxford, in 1989–1990, on a scholarship funded by Soros), it has now moved to Austria and is located in Vienna. Its links with Balliol continue: the current Rector is Shalini Randeria, mentioned above, one of the first cohort of women Rhodes Scholars at Oxford, who, though not a Balliol student, lived and worked at Holywell Manor. 

On leaving Balliol, Bill went on to found or overhaul numerous universities globally on behalf of Soros’s Open Society Foundations, whose board he joined, and the World Bank, in former Soviet Republics, the Middle East and the Global South – from Al-Qds University on the West Bank of Israel to the American University of Central Asia in Kyrgyzstan, as well as in Moscow, Minsk, Kyiv, Bucharest, Bratislava and Pristina, and visiting Albania, Bulgaria and Macedonia – all, as his Times obituary notes, ‘aimed at spreading the ethos of open academic debate so that when virgin democracies started to become another dictatorship in all but name, there were enough around not to be fooled’. 

Bill was married twice, first to the internationally acclaimed novelist Dorris Heffron, then teaching literature at Oxford and the Open University, a pioneer in the genre of young adult fiction and since 2013 chair of the Canadian Writers Union. His second marriage in 1989 was to Nancy Durham, an award winning Canadian foreign television correspondent, reporting from London for the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation and for the BBC. In 1994 she became a video journalist covering the break-up of Yugoslavia from all sides in the conflict. Her television work took her across Europe, the former USSR, Africa, Europe, and Iraq. After ending his work for Soros in 2016, Bill and Nancy planted a field of lavender on their farm near Abergavenny in mid Wales, the first to plant lavender in Wales on a field scale. They then expanded their operations, becoming the only distillers of lavender oil in Wales. Their company Welsh Lavender Ltd produced oil and developed body and face creams sold from their shop in Hay-on-Wye. As he wrote to a former student, Bill was there ‘fully engaged in writing my memoirs’. There are two daughters – one, Apple, a High Court Judge in Toronto, the other, Rain, recently appointed Director-General of the Confederation of British Industry – and seven grandchildren. He suffered from throat cancer to which he finally succumbed at the age of 79. 

It was in Wales that he embarked on his last academic venture, becoming the founding chairman of Black Mountains College, based in Talgarth, the first college in the UK dedicated to the study of climate change and sustainability. Its founder, Ben Rawlence, approached him for support. ‘Are we mad?’ Rawlence asked him, to which Bill replied, ‘Yes, but I’ll help you.’ The funding was secured and Black Mountains College admits its first cohort of students this autumn, studying for a BA in sustainable futures.

Lines on Bill Newton-Smith 

Alan Montefiore (Emeritus Fellow) 

I was myself a member of the small Appointments Committee that unhesitatingly recommended Bill to the College for election to a Tutorial Fellowship in Philosophy well over half a century ago, and for all the ensuing years that we were there together I could not have wished for a better all round colleague and, quite simply, friend. As a philosopher he had specialist knowledge and abilities in fields in which I have to confess to have always been very much an amateur; as a tutor he was always understandingly supportive of his students; and as a member of the Governing Body he was in many ways very effectively involved in the wider social and administrative affairs of the College. And his interests and very practical commitments extended, of course, well beyond those of the College and of Oxford as such – as indeed they are well recorded in the various obituaries that have already appeared. 

Bill was, of course, a good fifteen or so years younger than me, and I would never have expected to find myself outliving him in this way. I shall be far from alone among those who, one way and another, will find themselves very much missing his presence among us.

Photo credit: Photograph by Nancy Durham. 

Major General Sir Sebastian Roberts KCVO OBE

1973, BA Modern History
07 January 1954 — 09 March 2023

Lucian Roberts (1989) 

Sebastian John Lechmere Roberts was born in January 1954 at a military hospital in Aldershot. He was the eldest of ten. After prep school in Kensington, and boarding at Ampleforth, Sebastian came up to Oxford and learnt history at the feet of (amongst others) the great medievalist Maurice Keen (Fellow and Tutor in Modern History 1961–2000). He embraced all that College had to offer and thundered through university life. He delighted in the debating and wordplay of the Arnold and Brackenbury Society but turned down the invitation to push himself forward at the Union, when he refused to join Benazir Bhutto’s slate. He enthusiastically ran with his generation’s reincarnation of the Annandale dining society, and also accepted membership of the better known Bullingdon. Such was his confidence as he approached f inals, he was known to have announced to anyone who would listen that really all revision was a form of cheating and that one should only take into the examination halls what you had inside your mind. He exited his first paper chastised and admitted: ‘I was wrong.’ 

He left Oxford with a score of friends, a love of the academic, a love of the College, a clear understanding of how to read a wine list, and a third. This hurt. He was better than that and he knew it. Surprising many, he took his many talents to the Army, commissioning into the Irish Guards in 1977. He would go on to command them. Later he was appointed Major General Commanding the Household Division and General Officer Commanding London District. In 2007, he became the Senior Army Representative at the Royal College of Defence Studies, and he retired in 2010. While serving he made up for his undergraduate overconfidence and proved his military and academic credentials with his writing of the Armed Forces Covenant, specifically the moral component of the covenant. This influential work cemented the moral aspects of the relationship between the armed forces, society and the politicians who hold responsibility for how the armed forces are deployed. 

Upon retirement he held numerous posts: including being non-executive Chairman of the Military Mutual, a Trustee of the Royal Armouries and Master of the Girdlers’ Company. He was also an artist who designed Balliol’s 2022 Christmas card for the Master. 

His funeral was held at the Brompton Oratory; around 1,200 attended. He is survived by his wife Lady Elizabeth, four children and nine grandchildren.

Diarmaid Douglas-Hamilton

1958, BA Physics
17 June 1940 — 19 January 2023

Iain Douglas-Hamilton 

Diarmaid Douglas-Hamilton was born in Wiltshire on 17 June 1940. After his father, Lord David Douglas-Hamilton, squadron leader of 603 City of Edinburgh Squadron, was killed in 1944, Diarmaid’s mother moved to South Africa with her second husband. Diarmaid lived there for five years before returning to the UK, where he attended Gordonstoun School and won a scholarship to Balliol to read Physics. 

In 1960 on a skiing holiday in the Swiss Alps, he inadvertently touched a high-voltage cable with his ski stick. The shock catapulted him over a cliff and he tumbled 1,500 feet down a gully, before coming to a stop in a snowdrift. Recuperating in South Africa, he climbed mountains by day and watched stars by night. He immersed himself in astronomy at the Observatory in Cape Town, then enrolled in a PhD in Astrophysics at Harvard. 

He left Harvard to work for the military industrial complex of America (first at AVCO Everett Laboratories, then the Eaton Corporation), ultimately as a team leader in building what was then one of the largest lasers in the world. He would not reveal his work even to his brother Iain, although he once let slip that ‘the sudden dis-functioning of a Soviet geostationary satellite over New York was not entirely unconnected with my team’s work’. 

Diarmaid and his wife Meg, whom he married in 1983, co-founded Hamilton Thorne Inc, which built advanced laser systems for human and animal reproductive technology based on his inventions. One, LYKOS & LYKOS DTS, integrated lasers into the objective lens of a microscope, and is widely used to manipulate embryos and immature egg cells in women in IVF; another, the ‘motility analyser’, shines lasers through a solution of living sperms to assess their motion and health. Dairmaid, who was Chief Technology Officer, held some two dozen patents for devices and systems related to this work. 

Dairmaid climbed often in the Alps, the Cuillins of Skye and peaks in the Cape of Good Hope in South Africa. He held a pilot’s licence and flew thousands of miles in his Cessna 172. In one adventure he and Meg rented a seaplane and flew to Baffin Island, north of the Arctic circle, where they climbed Mt. Asgard. Their attachment to Scotland grew deeper over the years with frequent trips to the Isle of Raasay, where they had a house. 

Diarmaid died on 19 January 2023. Meg survives him, as do his adored stepchildren Matthias and Arabella Plum, their spouses Coco Plum and Jeffrey Goldberg, and two grandsons. He is also survived by his younger brother Iain and his wife Oria, his two nieces Saba and Mara and their six children, as well as by the large extended family on three continents descended from Diarmaid’s grandfather, the 13th Duke of Hamilton.

Norman Franklin

1946, BA Chemistry
27 January 1928 — 01 January 2023

Liz Thomson 

Norman FranklinNorman Franklin read chemistry as an undergraduate at Balliol from 1946 to 1949. He always remembered his time at Balliol with great pleasure and was a devoted attendee at gaudies. He took great pleasure that one of his children and two grandchildren also studied there. 

He died just shy of his 95th birthday, having worked all his life for Routledge & Kegan Paul, the family firm. He presided over it for 27 years. 

Certainly, Norman never behaved as though he owned the company. A colleague said, ‘If the floor had to be scrubbed or the cellar cleaned out, he would roll up his sleeves and do it. He’d never asked anyone to do something he wouldn’t do himself.’ On one occasion, Franklin clambered out of a window and on to the roof of the Store Street offices to rewire the telephone system. 

Norman oversaw a golden era in the company’s history, publishing books by some of the great post-War thinkers, including Bertrand Russell, Edmund Husserl, Theodor Adorno and Carl Jung, making the house a hotbed of left wing ideas. 

Norman was a pioneering feminist and under him the imprint Pandora was established. Its great successes included the path-breaking Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit by Jeanette Winterson, which won the Whitbread Prize. 

Sadly, two months after retiring, Norman’s wife Jill died suddenly. They had met at a Society of Young Publishers meeting when she was a designer at Chatto. He married Carol Gardiner, a copy-editor from RKP, 18 months later. Sadly, he outlived her too, because she died in 2007. 

Norman established a charitable trust in Jill’s memory, its support targeted at small charities with immediate impact, with areas of interest including refugees and asylum seekers, victims of domestic violence and prisoners’ education. He was also closely involved in a number of charities, sitting on their boards, giving help and advice, and supporting them himself. 

Norman was a passionate cyclist who liked to describe his journey from home to work in the city as ‘23 traffic lights and turn left’. In older age he used an electric bike. In 2017, aged 89, he and his sons cycled from Land’s End to John O’Groats, raising £120,000 for charity. Eventually, he switched to an electric trike. In November 2022, an accident on the latter caused a broken hip from which he sadly did not recover. 

Norman is survived by his four children, seven grandchildren and four great-grandchildren, to whom he was devoted.

Fr Ian Ker

1960, BA Literae Humaniores
30 August 1942 — 05 November 2022

Paul Shrimpton (1977) 

Ian KerIan Turnbull Ker was born in Nainital, India, on 30 August 1942 and moved to England with his family in 1947. From Shrewsbury School he went to read Classics at Balliol under three of the leading scholars of the time: Gordon Williams (Fellow and Tutor in Classics 1953–62), Russell Meiggs (Fellow 1939–1970), and R.M. Hare (Fellow 1947–1966). Ker completed a second degree in English literature at Corpus Christi College before moving to Trinity College, Cambridge, for a doctorate on George Eliot. After a spell teaching at the University of York, he abandoned his academic career to train for the priesthood, having become a Catholic during his years at Oxford. 

Ker stayed briefly at the Birmingham Oratory, where he got to know Charles Stephen Dessain (1929), the leading scholar on John Henry Newman, and completed his training in Rome. Once ordained, Fr Ker taught at the University of St Thomas in St Paul, Minnesota. After serving as a university chaplain at Oxford and then Southampton, he became parish priest at Burford in the Cotswolds; during these years he was part of the Theology Faculty of Oxford University and a research fellow at Blackfriars Hall. 

Over several decades Fr Ker managed to combine his priestly ministry with an impressive scholarly output. Besides critical editions of three of Newman’s most influential works – the Apologia pro Vita Sua, the Grammar of Assent and the Idea of a University – he co-edited four volumes of Newman’s Letter and Diaries (32 volumes) and worked in all the fields covered by Newman’s own ‘imperial intellect’. His John Henry Newman: A Biography (2009) has long been regarded as the definitive account of the most recent English saint; his scholarly biography of G.K. Chesterton (2011) is also much admired. In all he published over twenty books on Newman and was widely recognised as the leading scholar on his life and work. 

Fr Ker’s tireless energy saw him accepting invitations to speak about Newman all over the world, as well as organising symposia and international conferences. Not a few of those who met or listened to him were delighted by his bonhomie and wit, and found his company stimulating. His vivacity was much in evidence at a dinner to mark his 80th birthday last August, at which he was presented with a book of essays in his honour, which included pieces by three well-known cardinals. He died in Cheltenham on 5 November 2023.

Professor Sir Peter J. Morris FRS

Nuffield Professor of Surgery and Fellow 1974–2001; Emeritus Fellow from 2001
17 April 1934 — 29 October 2022

David Cranston (Emeritus Associate Professor of Surgery, Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences) and Freddie Hamdy (Nuffield Professor of Surgery and Professorial Fellow)

Peter MorrisPeter was born in Horsham in the state of Victoria, Australia, in 1934. His father, Stanley Morris, was a civil engineer, and a twice medal winner in the Premier Australian Football League (AFL). His mother, Mary (née Hennessy), was a pharmacist. His father died suddenly at the age of 49 from a heart attack, when Peter was 14, and tragedy hit again a year later when his younger brother, Stan, was killed in a car accident. 

At Melbourne University, Peter switched from engineering to medicine and was first introduced to immunology by Sir McFarlane Burnett, who later shared the Nobel Prize for Medicine with Sir Peter Medawar. He excelled at sport, representing Australia in university baseball and cricket. He graduated in 1957, started his surgical training in Melbourne, and married Jocelyn. They then travelled to England, working their passage on a cargo ship. 

He continued his surgical training in Southampton and was a surgical registrar at the Hammersmith Hospital when the first living non-related kidney transplant was performed. 

In 1964, he moved to a surgical resident post at the Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston. The following years were spent as a research fellow while continuing his surgical training under the direction of Professor Claude Welch, who had been President of the American College of Surgeons. He worked 120 hours a week, lucky to get two hours sleep when on call. The day began at 5.00am to see all the patients before the formal ward round at 6.15am . . . Not only was Welch a superb technical surgeon, but he remained calm and polite in theatre, however difficult the situation. Due to return to Melbourne in 1967, Morris received a phone call to say that the university was going through a financial crisis and his post had been frozen. On hearing this, David Hume, the Head of Surgery at the Medical College of Virginia, invited him to set up a tissue typing laboratory in what was then the biggest transplant unit in the world. Attracted by a –80°C freezer full of samples taken before and after every transplant, Morris accepted. He tested all those sera for antibodies with Paul Terasaki, who gave him his new micro assay trays. Together, they discovered that, contrary to popular opinion, lymphocytotoxic antibodies did appear after transplantation and their presence at the time of transplantation imposed a high risk of hyper-acute rejection. The importance of humoral immunity was then gradually accepted by the transplant community. 

He returned to Melbourne in 1968 to work as a transplant surgeon and to set up and direct the tissue transplantation laboratories, working with Professor Priscilla Kincaid-Smith, a nephrologist and renal pathologist, and a surgeon, Dr Vernon Marshall, who had started the transplant unit. There were often long nights as he was involved not only in the tissue typing of the donor and recipient, which was slow and tedious in those days, but also in the donor nephrectomy and the subsequent renal transplant, being performed continuously over a 15-hour time span. 

By now, he and Jocelyn had five children, who remember waiting together in a very hot car outside the Royal Melbourne Hospital, on occasions for one to two hours, while Morris did his Sunday ward round before taking them swimming . . . 

He was appointed as First Assistant in the Department of Surgery and became director of the Australian Kidney Foundation. From data of transplant outcomes, he showed that blood transfusion before transplantation, which could ‘sensitise’ patients, was associated with improved survival of donor kidneys, rather than making it worse, which was the prevailing opinion. This conundrum has never been satisfactorily explained.

The Oxford years 

In 1973, Peter Morris was on the point of accepting the Chair of Surgery at Adelaide University in South Australia when he had a phone call from Sir Richard Doll, Regius Professor of Medicine in Oxford, asking him if he would be interested in the Nuffield Chair of Surgery. Doll had been tipped off by a surgical colleague that Morris was about to take the chair at Adelaide. He travelled immediately and after discussion with senior scientists he agreed to apply. The electoral board confirmed his appointment, but Peter only learned of their decision when he received a congratulatory telegram from a friend in London who had seen the announcement in The Times! 

He moved to the chair in Oxford in 1974, where the department was in the doldrums following the death in office of his predecessor Phillip Allison, and became Professorial Fellow at Balliol College. Arriving at the old Radcliffe Infirmary on 4 August, he found his secretary, Joan Cracknell, who immediately handed him a note from Hans Krebs, whose office was along the corridor, inviting him for a cup of coffee. Krebs had won the Nobel Prize in Physiology in 1953 for the discovery of the citric acid cycle in 1937. Morris had no idea he was still alive and working! 

In Oxford he established the transplantation programme with the backing of Rosemary Rue, who was Chief Medical Officer of the Oxford Regional Health Authority at the time, and Dr Desmond Oliver, a New Zealander and former All Black, who was running one the biggest home haemodialysis units in Europe at the nearby Churchill Hospital. To that date the UK survival figures for renal transplantation were very poor: 40% of patients died within one year, and the graft survival rate was only 50%. 

The first two patients were transplanted on 29 and 30 January 1975 before and after midnight. Both kidney transplants were successful, and the patients lived for many years. Despite the early scepticism of many patients, who were aware of the poor outcomes after transplantation, there were soon more than a hundred patients on the waiting list. For the first few years he did most of the transplants himself but gradually he trained up a team of surgeons. He insisted on doing the living donor transplants himself, as the consequences of technical failure involved both donor and recipient. He followed the example of his mentor Claude Welch in always being courteous and unflappable. 

He was also a vascular surgeon and set up an academic department of vascular surgery that provided an excellent service to the region. Soon after arriving he was called in to see a patient whose aortic aneurysm was bleeding into his stomach. He saved his life by bypassing the problem, connecting the leg and arm circulations. The terrified junior doctor who had called him in later became his first Oxford DPhil student. For a time, he was the only surgeon to perform carotid endarterectomies – a risky procedure to prevent strokes. 

He developed an internationally renowned research programme in transplant immunology and made pioneering discoveries in the fields of tissue typing and cross matching which led to longer kidney graft survival and more organs being suitable for transplantation. He also started the successful Oxford Pancreatic Islet Research Programme for the treatment of diabetes. 

At Balliol, despite his busy schedule, he attended and contributed to Consilium and College meetings, and was always ready to assist anyone with medical matters in particular. He took an active part in College life, which he enjoyed as much as his commitments allowed, and after retirement as an Emeritus Fellow. 

He retired from the Nuffield Chair in 2001, with a three-day festschrift delivered by leading surgeons and scientists from around the globe, ending with a cricket match and banquet at Blenheim Palace. 

The Royal College of Surgeons’ years 

He was elected President of the Royal College of Surgeons of England, serving from 2001 until 2004, and was extremely energetic in this role. He visited five to six hospitals each month, to see how surgical services and training were being delivered. He would meet the CEO’s medical directors, consultants and trainees, separately, listening to the views of clinicians as to how improvements might be made and follow up on the actions taken. He would ignore artificial health service boundaries if he felt these were detrimental to patient services and safety. 

Despite his workload he enjoyed life with a fondness for fine wines, food and sport. He was the first President of the College to have Sky Sports put into the Presidential Office and Lodge, and would often walk into meetings late, rattling out the latest test match score. 

As Chairman of the RCS Research Board, he drove the implementation of the Research Fellowship Scheme, which has led to the appointment of more than 900 research fellows. He established and chaired a working party on transplantation in the UK, which led to the rationalisation of and improvements in the way organ transplant services were run. 

While President he realised that there were 19th-century human remains that had been taken from Aboriginal graves in Australasia and some of this material had ended up in the museums of the Royal College of Surgeons. Morris understood the Aboriginal spiritual belief that the body should be intact and repatriated more than 75 sets of remains to Australia and New Zealand. He also invited Sir Richard Doll to lead a working party to advise on the future of surgical audit, which led to the establishment of the Clinical Effectiveness Unit, bringing systematic methods to the collection and interpretation of surgical outcomes data. 

After demitting, he established the Centre for Evidence in Transplantation at the Royal College of Surgeons and the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine to evaluate the quality of evidence in the field of organ transplantation. He was responsible for the development of an electronic library of all randomised controlled trials in organ transplantation. 

And the rest . . . 

He later served as Chairman of the British Heart Foundation and President of the Medical Protection Society which provides medical indemnity for some 250,000 physicians worldwide. 

On one occasion when he was due to fly to New York he was asked to collect a donation for transplantation research at Heathrow from British Airways staff, one of whom was a patient. To his delight he was upgraded to Concorde and invited to the flight deck as the plane came in to land during a storm. He was impressed by how smooth the landing was. 

He was editor of the journal Transplantation and author of 800 papers. His book on Kidney Transplantation (1979), regarded as a classic, is now in its seventh edition. He was the founding editor of the Oxford Textbook of Surgery (1994). 

He was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society in 1994 and a Foundation Fellow of the Academy of Medical Sciences in 1998. In 1997, he was awarded the Lister Prize for his contributions to surgical science, and the Medawar Prize in 2006 for his contributions to transplantation. He was knighted for services to medicine in 1996 and he was made a Companion of the Order of Australia for services to medical sciences in 2004. Accomplished at both cricket and golf, he was overjoyed one day to be playing golf in Australia one hole ahead of Sir Donald Bradman. In 2002, he was a castaway on Desert Island Discs. 

His family was an important part of his life and their home in Oxford was always welcoming. Jocelyn would host the families of new arrivals to the Nuffield Department of Surgery (now the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences) for coffee mornings. Many family suppers were finished with an assortment of people being welcomed to the dinner table, where quality Australian wine would be consumed. 

Peter has been an inspiring academic surgeon, pioneer, innovator and scientist, and a role model for many generations of surgeons around the globe. It is impossible, in this short obituary, to do justice to his phenomenal career and achievements. He has always been a great support for the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences, diligently attending our annual away day, where the sharpness of his contributions during the presentations was always astounding. His regular warm incursions into the NDS offices for ‘a coffee and catch up’, and his generous advice and wisdom will be missed dearly and remembered fondly. Peter is one of the greatest figures of Oxford medicine, and an inspiration for any young trainee aspiring to become a successful academic and surgeon scientist. He is survived by his wife, Jocelyn, five children, eleven grandchildren, and three great grandchildren. 

This obituary was first published on the Nuffield Department of Surgical Sciences website and is reproduced by kind permission.

Postscript 

Martin Burton (Professor of Otolaryngology, Director of Cochrane UK and Research Fellow in Clinical Medicine) 

I remember Peter Morris from my first year as a clinical medical student in 1980–1981. Even though he was the Professor of Surgery, he was always friendly and welcoming to his students. But he had high standards and he expected the students to aspire to those too. In my final year, I had become friends with a visiting Australian elective student. He had ‘family friends’ in Oxford, who had invited him to visit. When he took me along for dinner with them, imagine my surprise to find myself sitting around the Morris’s kitchen table enjoying Peter and Jocelyn’s hospitality. That was in fact the beginning of a long relationship. Peter offered me help and advice as a junior doctor, encouraged me to go to the United States early in my career and kindly acted as a referee. It was a pleasure when I returned to Oxford and we moved to Summertown to realise that we were neighbours. And then – the icing on the cake – I joined Balliol and he was a colleague here also. A brilliant scientist, a deft and meticulous surgeon, and a charming, family man. He is much missed and very warmly remembered.

Photo credit: Sir Peter Morris by Jon R. Friedman, 2005. Reproduced by kind permission of the Royal College of Surgeons, England.

Dr Bruce Fairgray Harris AM

1946, BA Literae Humaniores
07 March 1921 — 30 July 2022

Dr Jonathan Harris (son)

Bruce HarrisBorn in 1921, Bruce grew up in rural New Zealand, attended Auckland Grammar School and completed his BA at the University of New Zealand in 1941 as New Zealand’s Top Scholar in Latin and Greek. 

After war service in the New Zealand Army, Bruce was awarded a Rhodes Scholarship to study ‘Greats’ at Balliol, where he was proud to have been tutored by Russell Meiggs (Fellow 1939–1970 and Honorary Fellow 1970–1989). He played hockey for Balliol and was Club Secretary. Four years on the Oxford Christian Union (OICCU) Executive introduced him to many in the worldwide evangelical student movement (IVF) who became lifelong friends. Another lifelong friendship was with his fellow New Zealand Rhodes Scholar (at Christ Church), George Cawkwell, who became Fellow and Praelector in Ancient History at University College, Oxford. Bruce also reminisced about the many occasions he heard C.S. Lewis speak. 

Bruce became Classics Senior Lecturer and Associate Professor at University of Auckland, 1950–1969. At the same time he undertook a London Bachelor of Divinity and New Zealand’s first PhD in Classical Studies. In 1970 he moved to Sydney where he helped Professor Edwin Judge build the emerging field of Ancient History at Macquarie University, establishing (with Dr Alanna Nobbs) a ground-breaking Research Project in Early Christian Papyri. His other research and teaching interests extended across the early Roman empire (he was a world authority on Dio Chrysostom of Prusa and the Roman Province of Bithynia), numismatics (he founded the collection at Macquarie), the New Testament, the history of classical thought, and the place of history and philosophy in human culture. Across his career Bruce supported secondary and tertiary education: he was Chairman of the Auckland Grammar Schools (1960s), founding Chair and President of the Society for Study of Early Christianity at Macquarie, on the Sydney Anglican Diocese’s executive Standing Committee (1976–1991) and Chairman of the Diocese’s Education Commission. 

Bruce was known for his gentle and humble character, sharp intellect, integrity, peaceableness, and remarkable memory. Married to Pamela Mary for 72 years, he had four sons, 13 grandchildren, and 30 great-grandchildren. In 2020, aged 99, he was made a Member of the Order of Australia (AM) for his significant service to education, veterans, and the community at large. Bruce was the eldest brother of Donald Renshaw Harris, QC (Hon) (1953, Fellow and Tutor in Jurisprudence 1956–1976, Senior Research Fellow 1977–1993, Emeritus Fellow 1993–2020).

Robin Blackhurst

1953, BA Jurisprudence
28 August 1934 — 26 July 2022

Tim Lewis (Worcester, 1957) 

Robin BlackhurstRobin Blackhurst was born on 28 August 1934 in Lytham St Anne’s. From his mother he inherited a lifelong love of poetry, literature, and theatre as well as sincere consideration for others; from his father, a passion for fishing and golf and a Lancastrian detestation of snobbery. 

At Shrewsbury School, Blackhurst abandoned the classics to read history. The head of Classics, Stacy Colman, Balliol double first in mods and greats, viewed such a choice as a mortal sin; Blackhurst dubbed Colman ‘the Pedant Laureate’. On hearing Blackhurst had been accepted by Balliol to read Jurisprudence, Colman responded with pained disgust whilst Blackhurst modestly considered his acceptance was due to his interview with Maurice Keen (1954 and Fellow and Tutor in Modern History 1961–2000). 

At Balliol, Blackhurst became a protégé of Jack Good (1952) and succeeded him in his second year as President of OUDS, although Blackhurst won the unkind title ‘the non-acting President’ because he never needed to act in his lead roles, notably in The Taming of the Shrew, where his Petruchio was cast against a professional American actress. Blackhurst also played in the Oxford second golf team. 

After Oxford, Blackhurst faced his national service in the 13th/18th Royal Hussars. At Mons Officer Cadet School he won the Sword of Honour, receiving the award from Field Marshal Montgomery. On demobilisation, he toyed with the idea of joining Blackhurst & Blackhurst, the family law firm. Instead, he joined the Bank of London and South America, as personal assistant to Sir George Bolton, the chairman. In 1963 he married Graciela Cavagnaro, and they settled in Buenos Aires. 

Over the next 40 years, Blackhurst held a variety of senior banking positions. He was fluent in Spanish and Portuguese. Skilled at making friends, he played bridge, golf and backgammon. 

In 1995, he married Stephanie Wild, a commodity trading executive. They lived in São Paulo, Rio de Janeiro, New York, and finally Florida. 

Blackhurst had an abiding interest in history, a great love of literature – he was able to recite Shelley and Wordsworth from memory – and a passion for fishing for sea trout in Alaska and Tierra del Fuego, salmon in Siberia and the River Spey in Scotland, and giant eels in Lancashire. 

He died on 26 July 2022 after a brief battle against a severe blood infection, outlasting his beloved wife Stephanie by four days. He is survived by his daughters, Alexandra and Deborah, and his stepchildren, Adrienne and Brookes.

Dr Alastair Howatson

Fellow and Tutor in Engineering Science 1965–1995 and Emeritus Fellow from 1995
31 January 1928 — 18 June 2022

Paul Buckley (Emeritus Fellow) 

Alastair HowatsonAlastair’s arrival at Balliol as Tutor in Engineering Science in 1965 rescued the College from an unexpected problem. Perhaps I should explain. Balliol was one of the first Oxford colleges to establish a Tutorial Fellowship in Engineering Science (there were none prior to 1958). The first holder of the post was Les Woods, who had started in early 1961, coming from the University of New South Wales in Sydney, where he already had the position of Professor. However, the University role to which Les came as the other side of his Oxford joint appointment was that of ‘Demonstrator’ (equivalent to what we now know as ‘University Lecturer’). Les had quickly become frustrated at the lack of promotion opportunities in the Department of Engineering Science, and in 1964 had jumped ship to the Mathematical Institute, where he became Reader in Applied Mathematics (and in 1970 Professor of Mathematics). Les’s account of this saga can be found elsewhere.1 It posed a problem for Balliol. Although Les continued with Balliol tutorial teaching in engineering until 1970, the removal of the College’s direct link with the University’s engineering department was clearly unfortunate. In response, College resolved to recruit another Tutor in Engineering Science who would also be a University Lecturer in Engineering Science, and it was to this post that Alastair was appointed in 1965. Although not reached by quite the route College had intended, this was a good outcome. In Alastair the College had found an excellent tutor, who would serve Balliol and many cohorts of Balliol engineering undergraduates with dedication, ability, and above all kindness for the next 30 years. 

Alastair was not a great sharer of details of his family life. But true to another feature of his character, he thoughtfully provided information on his early years, specifically for including in his funeral’s Order of Service. From this we learn that his father was a joiner and he came from a line of craftsmen – blacksmiths, millwrights and stonemasons; all jobs involving designing things and making them: the very stuff of engineering. So perhaps it is no surprise that Alastair was inspired to pursue a career in engineering. He was of the generation that spent many of their school years during wartime, in his case attending school in the village of Lasswade, just south of Edinburgh. It was as the war ended in 1945 that he went to Edinburgh University to study Electrical Engineering. The next step was typical among engineering graduates of those days. Alastair went from university to a two-year graduate apprenticeship in industry, to obtain practical experience that was then lacking from university engineering courses. He joined the well-known firm Metropolitan Vickers in Manchester, and continued there for a further two years designing hydroelectric generators. He clearly enjoyed it: he described it as ‘an extremely stimulating environment’. At the time, the subject of electronics was taking off, and in 1952 Alastair returned to Edinburgh University for a one-year course on that subject, during which he clearly impressed the staff, because he was invited to stay on and complete a PhD. His research was on the engineering of A.C. circuit-breakers: vital components of many electrical devices. With the PhD under his belt, he spent a year as postdoctoral researcher at Purdue University in Indiana in the USA, and then two years as a Research Fellow at Cambridge University, where he pursued further the subject of his PhD research. A great bonus of the Cambridge years was his meeting Margaret, a Girton classicist, and they married in 1959. 

There followed four years at Sheffield University as Lecturer in Electrical Engineering, before Alastair moved to Oxford, to a University Lectureship in Engineering Science in 1963. At that stage he had no formal college attachment. The University’s Department of Engineering Science was in the throes of a rapid expansion, with several new academic staff arriving. Colleagues from those days speak of how Alastair brought to the department much valued expertise in, and practical experience of, designing electrical machines.

Having added to his University Lectureship the post of Tutor in Engineering Science at Balliol in 1965, Alastair was soon busy contributing to College life in other ways too. In particular he helped establish the new Balliol–St Anne’s Graduate Institution, where Balliol (a men-only college in those days) collaborated with St Anne’s (then still a women-only college) to provide accommodation and a social centre for graduate students from both colleges, in Holywell Manor and the Martin Building opposite, across St Cross Road. The new institution opened in 1967, under the Praefectus-ship of Russell Meiggs (Fellow 1939–1969 and Honorary Fellow 1970–1989). When he retired in 1969, Alastair took over as Praefectus for the next two years. This meant the Howatson family residing in the Praefectus’ house within Holywell Manor, and hence living at close quarters with the other residents. St Anne’s then Tutor for Graduates, Judith Hart, who had a small room in Holywell Manor overlooking the garden, later recalled2 hearing the three Howatson children playing in the garden, commenting that their presence helped provide a beneficial ‘element of family atmosphere’. The Praefectus role in those days was not without challenges, some of which Alastair later recalled in the history of Holywell Manor compiled by Oswyn Murray (Emeritus Fellow).2 Margaret3 mentioned another to me recently – students from the USA, about whom US authorities would want to know: were they dodging the draft? It was the era of the Vietnam war. Nevertheless, I am sure Alastair enjoyed this spell of relating closely with students and building a new mixed community for graduates. He always seemed to feel at home when surrounded by students, and former students. He was a regular attender at Gaudies, and never missed the annual dinner in College for present and former Lubbock Scholars (holders of the College’s senior scholarship in Engineering). 

In the 1970s and 1980s student numbers were growing and Alastair acquired help in tutoring the engineering students, with College’s appointment of a second Fellow and Tutor in Engineering Science: John Bridgwater in 1973 and then, when he left, Peter Whalley in 1980. However, Alastair was also by then also taking on other big commitments within College. He served as Tutor for Admissions from 1981 to 1984, and then took on the role of Vice-Master and chairman of Executive Committee from 1987 to 1990. He thereby oversaw the transition to a new Master, when Anthony Kenny retired in 1989 and Baruch Blumberg took over. This role must have suited Alastair well, benefiting as it did from his natural abilities, both to nurture friendly relations with the student representatives on Executive Committee and to manage diplomatically the differing views among Fellows. Alastair returned to the role for his last year before retirement, 1994–1995. 

It was during his last few years before retirement that I arrived as Balliol’s third Tutor in Engineering Science in 1990. New to the College, I benefited greatly from Alastair’s patience, his self-deprecating sense of humour and the generosity with which he showed me the ropes, guiding me through Balliol’s ways of doing things.

Alongside his many contributions to College, of course, Alastair was also busy in the Department of Engineering Science, teaching Electrical Engineering and pursuing his research. I was myself an Oxford engineering undergraduate in the 1960s. I recall vividly attending lectures by the Scotsman with the long fringe falling over his forehead, explaining the basics of electricity and electronics (my least favourite branch of the subject) in such an engaging manner and with such lucidity that even I could follow. Alastair was also a natural communicator on paper. He certainly loved writing. In 1969 he published his first undergraduate textbook,4 which provides clear, broad, coverage of the aspects of electricity of interest to engineers at the time. Much later, just after retiring, he published a second undergraduate textbook,5 on electric circuits and their applications, which I am told is still popular with students. 

Another example of Alastair’s interest in, and sensitivity to, the needs of students was his collaboration with two department colleagues (Peter Lund and Joe Todd) to bring together in one volume a wide collection of assorted information useful for engineers, especially student engineers, titled Engineering Tables and Data but familiar to Oxford engineers as simply HLT. Since its original publication in 1972,6 it has been taken over by the department and revised editions have been produced, with contributions from several other members of staff. It has proved invaluable to students and staff. Of all the books acquired by Oxford engineering students over the last 50 years, I am guessing HLT is the one most likely to be still on their shelves. 

Alastair’s research interest was the interactions between electricity and gases, and their management in electrical devices. Normally, gases act effectively as electrical insulators. However, very high gradients of voltage applied to a gas can strip electrons off the gas atoms, producing a mix of positively charged particles (atoms missing some electrons) and negatively charged particles (free electrons). The result is called a ‘plasma’ and the voltage then produces a very high current flow and dramatically high energy dissipation in the gas. Momentarily this can heat the gas to several thousand degrees C, to the point where strong light is emitted, as in a lightning strike or, on a smaller scale, in a spark in the gap between two wires. This is called an electrical discharge in the gas. Alastair made notable contributions to the study of this phenomenon and its management, resulting in a string of journal papers. The work also led to Alastair’s first book,7 begun during his time in Sheffield and followed by a second edition later during his Oxford days.

Science. He played a pivotal role in helping to build its self-identity, by becoming its de facto in-house historian. Alastair became fascinated by the history of how engineering had developed within the University, and he researched it and communicated his findings to the Oxford engineering community. Compared to other universities, Oxford was relatively late in including engineering within its repertoire of academic subjects. It was not until 1908 that the University began to do so formally, with the establishment of a Chair in Engineering Science: a post held by Charles Frewen Jenkin. However, Alastair told us of much earlier activities in Oxford that we would badge these days as ‘engineering’. He even discovered that the subject was being taught from 1886, in the Millard Laboratory set up for this purpose by Trinity College at their entrance off St Giles, right next door to Balliol. In the 1980s the department formed an alumni society: the Society of University Oxford Engineers. Its first step was to establish an annual lecture to which alumni would be invited: the Jenkin Lecture, which is still going strong and is now part of the University’s Meeting Minds alumni weekend. In 1988 Alastair gave the inaugural Jenkin Lecture, titled ‘A Century of Oxford Engineering’. He continued researching the topic after retirement and when, in 2008, the department celebrated the centenary of the establishment of Jenkin’s Chair with, among other things, a series of lectures by members of staff, Alastair contributed a talk on ‘History of the Department of Engineering Science’ and also produced a fascinating book on the subject.8 

Another contribution that Alastair continued to make after retirement was supporting the Maurice Lubbock Memorial Fund: the major fund established by the Lubbock family in 1957, to help promote the subjects of Engineering and Management in Balliol and the wider university. While a Tutorial Fellow, Alastair had served for many years as secretary to the fund’s trustees. On retiring in 1995 he handed on this baton to me but became a trustee himself, continuing to offer greatly valued words of wisdom in this capacity until he retired from that role in 2012. 

To those of us who knew him, Alastair seemed to be one of those people who would remain sprightly and alert for ever. Long after retiring he would walk from his home on the Woodstock Road, or travel into Oxford by bus from his cottage in the countryside, to enjoy a College dinner and conversation with colleagues. But eventually he fell ill, and he died on 18 June 2022. I hope it will be clear from the above what a debt of gratitude is owed to Alastair by Balliol and the University, for his contributions over many years. 

1 Against the Tide by L.C. Woods, Institute of Physics, 2000. 

2Holywell Manor: An Anecdotal History, compiled by O. Murray, 2007. 

3Margaret Howatson became Fellow and Tutor in Classics at St Anne’s College from 1967, retiring in 1997. She is now Emeritus Fellow of St Anne’s. 

4Principles of Applied Electricity by A.M. Howatson, Chapman and Hall, 1969. 

5Electrical Circuits and Systems by A.M. Howatson, Oxford University Press, 1996. 

6Engineering Tables and Data by A.M. Howatson, P.G. Lund and J.D. Todd, Chapman and Hall, 1972. 

7An Introduction to Gas Discharges by A.M. Howatson, Pergamon Press, 1st edition 1965, 2nd edition 1976. 8Mechanicks in the Universitie by A.M. Howatson, Department of Engineering Science, University of Oxford, 2008. 

Photo credit: Alastair Howatson while relaxing in the quad with students after Finals in 1979. Photograph by Gary Calder (1976).

 

Thomas Carpenter

1952, BA Engineering Science
27 April 1932 — 11 June 2022

Douglas Carpenter (St John’s, 1985), son 

TG (Tom) Carpenter died on 11 June 2022, aged 90. 

Tom studied Engineering at Balliol, after completing his primary and secondary education in London and Devon and his national service in Britain and Hong Kong. At Balliol he lived in College and then in Holywell Manor, where he encountered the young David Cornwell (John Le Carré). Tom was a stalwart of both the Oxford University Athletics Club and the Achilles, taking part in the relays and winning several titles in Long and Triple Jump (he also competed for London AC and Wycombe Phoenix). 

After graduating in 1955 Tom took up a career in civil engineering, serving Sir Alexander Gibb & Partners (later Jacobs) for most of his career and living for many years in Iran, Pakistan and Sri Lanka, where he was involved in a number of irrigation and power generation projects. He married Elizabeth Green after meeting her in Iran in the 1950s and they remained together until her death in 2011. Tom returned to the UK in the late 1970s and took up residence in south Oxfordshire, where he remained for more than 45 years. He and his immediate family maintain close links with the University and Tom himself was regularly present at Balliol events until very recently. 

After retiring from Jacobs, Tom briefly served as a consultant at the newly set up European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, advising on environmental issues and on railways. In his later years he took to writing and he published a number of books on the environmental impact of railways and on construction and the landscape; at the time of his death he was still actively researching in the fields of climate change and development. 

Tom maintained a love of mountaineering throughout his life and climbed and walked extensively in the west highlands of Scotland, in Pakistan – where he knew well the pioneering climber Trevor Braham – and in Iran. 

Tom is survived by his son and three grandchildren.

Professor Joseph Raz FBA

Tutorial Fellow in Law 1972–1985, Professor of the Philosophy of Law 1985–2006, Emeritus Fellow from 2006
21 March 1939 — 02 May 2022

Timothy Endicott (Emeritus Fellow)

Joseph RazFifty years ago, in 1972, Balliol appointed a new Law Fellow who would transform legal philosophy and re-animate much of moral and political philosophy. He cast light on ever-more basic problems concerning the significance of human autonomy, the nature and potential legitimacy of authority, and the nature of reason and reasons. He did it through brilliant, creative thinking, with sensitivity and sheer perseverance. 

Joseph Zaltsman was born in Haifa in 1939, while Palestine was ruled by the United Kingdom under a League of Nations mandate. He was already longing to do philosophy while still a school student, and he went to community college lectures in philosophy. With Peter Hacker (who would, like Joseph, become a renowned Oxford philosopher) he was part of a discussion group at their school in Haifa, a group that together tackled Plato and Aristotle, Berkeley and Spinoza. 

Joseph studied philosophy at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem while also completing an outstanding law degree. Having met the famous Oxford legal philosopher H.L.A. Hart in Israel (and having pointed out an error in the argument of Hart’s lecture), Joseph went to University College, Oxford, to study for the DPhil in Law from 1964–1967. His thesis was published by OUP as The Concept of a Legal System (1970, 2nd ed. 1980). He returned to Israel to work as a lecturer at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. He married Yael Rappaport, and they both took the surname ‘Raz’, which they invented from Rappaport and Zaltsman. They moved to Oxford with their son Noam in 1970, for Joseph to take up a Research Fellowship at Nuffield College. Joseph continued to bring up Noam in Oxford after he and Yael were divorced later in the 1970s. 

Joseph taught at Balliol as a philosophy Lecturer in 1971–1972, and was appointed Fellow in Law in 1972. In a reference letter for Joseph, recommending his appointment, Hart wrote, ‘I have not met anyone of equal power and originality as a philosopher of law or student of jurisprudence’. And yet Hart commented, by way of qualification, 

When Raz first came to me his work manifested, besides its signal value, a tendency to move at a very high (though always rigorous) level of abstraction without affording his reader adequate help in the form of examples or explanatory discussion. I remember almost having to beg for the examples; and some critics, who have hailed his book as an important one, have complained of the difficulty of following him through the new territory he has opened up. 

Nevertheless, Hart backed Joseph for a Fellowship in Law because he thought that his experience in teaching at Hebrew University had improved his approach, and because of Joseph’s ‘growing interest in less abstract aspects of legal and social phenomena’. 

So Balliol hired Joseph and in just three years, while learning how to teach English law, he completed the monumental achievement of Practical Reason and Norms (1975, 2nd ed. 1990). This short, cogent book offered a new understanding of the nature of reasons and rules and, therefore, of law. The Authority of Law (1979, 2nd ed. 2009) showed his growing interest in ‘less abstract aspects of legal and social phenomena’, as Hart put it. At the centre of these two works – and of Joseph’s jurisprudence – was a sense of the value of human autonomy which shaped his original account of the authority that institutions and individuals claim over people. Together with his doctorate, these two works of the 1970s set out a general theory of law, explaining its systematic and institutional nature, its functions, its distinctive techniques, its role in society, the importance of coercion, and much concerning its relations to morality, including the limits of its legitimacy. 

Joseph’s work always centred on the practical questions of what may be done and what is to be done. All through that work runs the principle of autonomy – that it is ‘one’s right and duty to act on one’s judgment of what ought to be done’. If my self-direction is valuable, and is something that I should cherish and that others should respect, how can it be right for me to accept any person’s or institution’s claim to authority over me? How could the question ‘what am I to do?’ be answered by the mere say-so of a town council, or a court, or a parliament? Joseph thought that such authorities as these, by claiming to determine a conclusion for my practical reasoning, implicitly claim not only to give me a reason in favour of doing this or that, but also to give me a conclusive reason not to act on other considerations – considerations that would otherwise have been good and sufficient reasons for me to act or not to act. This insight, and the rational possibilities that it captures, resolve a seeming contradiction between authority and autonomy into a mere tension. But that tension brought to Joseph’s writing a sustained ambivalence toward the authority of law. He was against anarchism on the ground that it is not impossible for the law’s claims to be legitimate. Yet as Hart pointed out, it was Joseph’s view that law necessarily claims a form of moral authority that it necessarily lacks. Its legitimacy cannot have the unlimited scope that, in his view, law claims. 

Along the way, in a few pages in Practical Reason and Norms, Joseph departed radically from Hart’s explanation of social rules (and, therefore, from his theory of law). Hart was a moral philosopher who thought that moral philosophy is so very difficult and so controversial that it is hard to be confident that moral propositions can be true or false; law on the other hand is a social practice that can be elucidated without moral theorising, through sensitive attention to facts as to what people do and are disposed to do in society, and as to the social meanings of those facts. 

At this point, Joseph diverged from the teacher for whom he had high regard and a deep affection, and for whose instincts and attitudes he had much sympathy. Joseph never expressed in his work any doubt as to the objectivity of moral rights and duties. And he thought that if you have a legal right or duty, that means that the law purports to confer or to impose a moral right or duty, which the law enforces through its systematic, institutionalised techniques. This approach made the theory of law a part of the general theory of practical reason, so that the question of whether the law ought to be obeyed lies at the centre of jurisprudence (whereas to Hart, it was a peripheral question, detached from his account of the concept of law). In common with natural law theory, Joseph believed that the normativity of law and morality are one (since the law claims to impose moral duties), and that ‘There are inherent connections between legal concepts and moral concepts, and between law and morality.’ Yet Joseph also thought, contrary to natural law theory, that it is an open question whether law actually has, in any situation, the moral authority that it always claims for itself. 

As Joseph was preparing the manuscript for The Authority of Law in 1978, he met a new librarian and scholar of Aristophanes at Balliol, Penelope Bulloch (Emeritus Fellow). They agreed that she would help him with the editing, and they never looked back. Their partnership is reflected in the fact that in each of Joseph’s later books, to the end of his life, Penny is thanked at particular points or in the introduction. In his doctoral work, Joseph was already able to use the English language with precision, to telling effect. And he was always doing something so difficult that the prose was never going to be easy reading. But Joseph had to communicate successfully, and he did that very much better with Penny’s help. Communicating effectively meant being pushed further to unpack and to clarify his ideas, and to express them in more carefully chosen words, and with greater generosity to the reader. You can experience the results for yourself if you read The Concept of a Legal System, and then compare it with anything that Joseph wrote after 1978. Jurisprudence owes Penny a great debt. 

While developing his theory of law, Joseph was writing the series of striking essays in political philosophy that would come together in The Morality of Freedom (1986). The book develops an original theory of legitimate state action by unpacking and articulating the understanding of human autonomy that Joseph had been working to elucidate since the 1970s. That is an instance of the practice Joseph established, of going back and forth over areas that he had traversed before, making dramatic progress by revisiting problems and refining his approach to them. The Morality of Freedom completed his account of authority by arguing that in the right conditions, I can advance my own autonomy by obeying an authority: if I will do better at acting on the reasons that apply to me by doing so, then authority isn’t merely reconcilable with my autonomy; it provides me with a service that I can use in living a life that is genuinely my own. This service conception of authority came together with a provocative claim about autonomy itself: that its value depends on the value of the options that a person may choose to pursue. Indeed, that is why an authority can provide a service: in many settings it operates to enlarge and to enrich the options before me, making my life better partly by virtue of the very demands it makes on me. 

That approach to autonomy had profound implications for political theory. It may seem obviously true that, as Joseph argued in The Morality of Freedom, the state ought to promote the good of persons. But the idea ran against the tide of Western liberal political theory. The tide was embodied in John Rawls’ famous argument that the state ought to act on principles of justice that can be identified without ever judging what is good or bad. Joseph, who had met Rawls in Oxford, found this argument, and the theory it gave rise to, deeply implausible, and he avoided discussing it for some years, until its wild popularity made discussion necessary. His response was that the state ought to promote human autonomy, the value of which inescapably depends on the value of the choices available to the individual. It follows that the state needs to act on the basis of judgments as to what alternatives are valuable for individuals. 

Ironically, given his stature in the field today, Joseph did not on the whole feel well qualified for political philosophy. He had the expertise in law that he needed for legal philosophy, but he thought that in political philosophy more generally, real progress called for expertise in economics and social studies. That was not his expertise, and his solution was to work at a level of abstraction that was designed to show how and why sound political judgment demands expertise in economics and intelligent understanding of social needs and social goods. And along the way, in The Morality of Freedom, he wrote deeply original work of enduring importance on the plurality and incommensurability of values, and he argued against equality as a requirement of political justice, just at a time when equality seemed to many to be the ultimate political ideal and ‘the definitive belief of political liberalism’.

As Joseph was completing The Morality of Freedom, the University took notice of his achievement by using its rarely invoked ad hominem process for making a college tutor into a University Professor. Joseph’s pattern of work changed with his role, so that from that time on virtually all of his teaching involved presenting his newest thoughts in graduate seminars. He was still teaching jurisprudence, and the work collected in Ethics in the Public Domain (1994) brought fresh understanding to jurisprudential problems that he had addressed earlier in his career (the obligation to obey the law, the theory of authority, the rule of law), as well as pursuing the implications of his political philosophy for freedom of speech, national self-determination, multiculturalism, and the theory of democracy. While he was writing Ethics in the Public Domain, Joseph began visiting Columbia University during Michaelmas Term, participating in Ronald Dworkin’s and Thomas Nagel’s autumn seminars at New York University, and making Columbia an exciting and challenging philosophical destination for students, and for visitors to Joseph’s own seminars there. In 2002 he became a member of the Columbia Law School faculty. 

In the 1990s Joseph went more deeply into problems in the general philosophy of reason and value. As he traversed and re-traversed the terrain of human reason, his work was liable to become less abstract at some points and more abstract at others, as he moved on from his account of the relation between human autonomy and value to address relations between reason and value, and the nature of normativity in general. 

Joseph outlined this work on normativity in Engaging Reason (2000), the demanding themes of which he developed somewhat more accessibly in his Seeley Lectures at Cambridge (Value, Respect and Attachment, 2001) and his Tanner Lectures at Berkeley (The Practice of Value, 2003). In all those explorations, he offered what has proved to be a delicate and persuasive reconciliation of the universality of value with its diversity and its dependence on social practices. Fundamental moral values are universal values in the abstract, but our access to them, and the ways in which they are available to us, depend on social phenomena and on their history and on our experience of them. The depths and complexities of this work on normativity engaged Joseph further in his last two books: From Normativity to Responsibility (2011), and The Roots of Normativity (edited with an introduction by Ulrike Heuer, 2022). These are studies in the foundations of morality and of practical reason in general. Yet they are even more basic than practical reason, because there are norms not only for action and intention (and therefore, for practical reasoning) but also for belief, for emotions, and for attitudes. Normativity is a property of anything that makes an action or intention, or belief, or emotion, or attitude, appropriate or required. If a rule is to be followed, it is normative; if an authority is to be obeyed, it is normative; if a stranger’s statement that it has just turned 5.00pm is to be believed, it is normative. Joseph explained it all in terms of reasons, and gave a distinctive account of practical reasons as based on values. That approach confronted him with a complex agenda, to explain relations between reasons and value. But very often, reasons do not demand actions or intentions or emotions or beliefs, but only make them appropriate or optional. So Joseph was careful not to overrate the extent to which our rational capacities ought to shape our lives. 

It might seem that Joseph was leaving the study of law to become a philosopher of reason. But his work in philosophy of law was crucial and formative for his approach to philosophy in general, and he would keep revisiting it. The law gave him a profoundly useful context for thinking about autonomy, and value, and reasons. His most abstract work had its origins in his work on the theory of law. In the 2000s he saw himself as doing ‘practical philosophy: legal, political, and moral’. He made some of his most important contributions to legal studies in Between Authority and Interpretation (2009), one of the two most sustained reflections on interpretation in the entire history of legal philosophy. The other, of course, is Ronald Dworkin’s Law’s Empire (1986), which presents law itself as an ‘interpretive practice’, and argues that law is not made by the exercise of legal authority, but rather is the set of moral principles that would be identified by the best constructive interpretation of the legal practices of the community. Joseph, in sharp contrast, offered an account of interpretation that was informed by his theory of authority. Interpretation is an explanation or display of the meaning of an object – the relevant objects, in the case of law, being acts undertaken in the exercise of law-making power (by law makers, and persons exercising private legal powers to make wills, etc.). Understood in that way, interpretation can be necessary for working out the legal effect of an exercise of legal power such as the enactment of a statute. And interpretation, when carried out with legal authority, involves a creativity that is itself law-making. 

Joseph had a fearsome reputation for his contributions to seminar discussions, and for his critical reading of his students’ work. He did his students the great honour of treating them just as he treated Professor Dworkin, focusing acutely on the problem at hand and saying precisely what he thought the problem called for. Whether the discussion was with a student or a colleague, Joseph’s interest was never in any contest between minds but in the problems, and in the understanding that proper consideration of them might yield. His seminars with John Finnis in Oxford in the 1990s were brilliant events, partly because of the new work that one or the other would present each week, and partly because either of them might break new ground on the spur of the moment, as each of them said what they thought, in their most rigorous and considered view, in the course of the discussion that arose out of a presentation. But the students would have been disappointed had they expected any kind of a celebrity wrestling match, of legal positivist vs natural law theorist, liberal vs conservative, as they might have seen it. Both Joseph and Professor Finnis were concerned only with the problems, never with the blood sport aspect of academic jurisprudence. 

And even at the acme of abstraction, the problems that captivated Joseph always concerned the actuality of living a life. As Ulrike Heuer wrote in her introduction to The Roots of Normativity (2022), ‘Raz tries to stay at all times close to the phenomena as we know them.’ As Joseph himself once put it at a conference, ‘As legal philosophers our task is to perceive things with as much sensitivity and acuteness as we can and then to construct conceptual frameworks to illuminate those phenomena.’ 

Many of Joseph’s friends were philosophers (quite a few of them former doctoral supervisees who might not have predicted that they would become personal friends); these friends and Joseph himself tended to keep company in art galleries, or films, or walking across London or New York, all the while (though not in the films) talking about art or Formula One racing or reality TV or theatre, and above all, about people. Joseph’s dedication to photography – both an art to him and a fascinating technology – shows something of his character that I wish I could put into words, involving a longing for clarity and structure, a familiarity with disorder, and a readiness to be surprised by light. Perhaps he put some of those habits of mind and emotion into words in his writing. 

I haven’t gone into his pathfinding contributions on the morality of promising, on intention, on whether there is a moral obligation to obey the law, on the possibility of change in moral principles, on the nature of rights and of duties, on group rights, on aggregation and maximization . . . But in order to tell you about Joseph I have chosen to focus on his books, because Joseph the person is there to be heard, for those who knew his voice or want to know it. Those who open his books in the future have a great opportunity: they can take on the challenge of what Hart called, 50 years ago, ‘following him through the new territory he has opened up’. 

I am very grateful for help and advice from Penelope Bulloch, Noam Raz, and Paul Davies, and I benefited greatly from Tim Macklem's helpful reading of a draft.

Anthony Arblaster

1958, BA Modern History
20 April 1937 — 15 April 2022

Norman Coles (1957) 

Anthony Arblaster was a historian and a socialist. He was educated at Christ’s Hospital School before completing his National Service, after which he went up to Balliol. 

As well as history and political theory – and politics – he loved music and opera and friendship and discussion. 

After Balliol, he worked for some years at Tribune. His commitment to socialism was evident both in political theory and his activism. He stood as a Labour candidate in the then very Tory constituency of Hastings and Rye. Later, he lived and worked in Sheffield and Manchester, where he made distinguished contributions to teaching and research in political theory and philosophy, notably in his book Democracy. 

Indeed, like R.H Tawney many years before him, Anthony was not just a thinker within the socialist tradition – he also lived his beliefs.

Professor Godfrey Fowler OBE

College Doctor 1974–1991; Professorial Fellow, Balliol, and Clinical Reader in General Practice, Oxford University, 1978–1997; Emeritus Fellow from 1997
01 October 1931 — 29 March 2022

Martin Burton (Professor of Otolaryngology, Director of Cochrane UK and Research Fellow in Clinical Medicine) 

Godfrey FowlerGodfrey Fowler was one of Balliol’s towering medical figures. We met regularly from the time I f irst arrived at Balliol as a Lecturer and the meetings were a delight. He was kind and generous, and always interested in what the medical students and his medical colleagues were doing. In 2015 a group of students were mesmerised by the tales he told as he and I held a ‘conversazione’ at a Medical Society meeting in the Master’s Drawing Room, discussing his life. It was a very special occasion with wonderful stories about his time as a student and then a practitioner. He was a general practitioner of the old school, the likes of which we shall never see again.

 Whilst I was flattered to be asked to write something about him for this publication, I also knew that I could never do his life justice, having known him only latterly. John Jones knew him very considerably longer, and delivered a moving address at his funeral. This we offer to you now in fond remembrance of a great medical colleague. 

Funeral address 

John Jones (1961 and Emeritus Fellow) 

Godfrey Fowler was a dear friend for more than 50 years, as my own doctor, as Balliol’s doctor, as a Fellow of Balliol, and as an Emeritus Fellow. 

He was born in 1931, in the rural Worcestershire village of Wolverley. His parents were not at all well off, and he was a scholarship boy at Sebright, a local minor public school. He showed his strength of character there by refusing to join the school’s Army Cadets on conscientious grounds. The headmaster was cross, and told him that whenever the cadets were exercising he was to work on something demanding in the school library. He chose Gibbon’s The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. 

There was no Oxbridge tradition at Sebright, but the chemistry master urged him to aim high and enter the Oxford Scholarship Exam despite the headmaster’s discouragement. He was surprised to be awarded an Exhibition by University College, but he must have stood out because he had contrived to demonstrate thorough knowledge of Gibbon in a General Paper essay. When he arrived in Oxford in 1950 he felt out of place because he thought his contemporaries were from ‘posh schools’, which was true, and were cleverer than him, which was not. But he soon entered into the swing of things, which in his case involved joining the Alpine Club and Oxford roof-climbing at night. Imagine him on top of the Radcliffe Camera. 

After graduating as a BA and BM, he spent five years in London completing his medical training and gaining experience. There was an expectation that he would specialise in paediatrics, but he had long decided that he wanted to be a GP. In 1959 he joined Dr Alan Richards in his Oxford practice as an assistant, on a trial basis. Godfrey was associated with the practice, which is now located at 19 Beaumont Street, for the rest of his life as partner, senior partner, honorary partner and finally as a patient. 

Lord Florey, the Provost of The Queen’s College, who was a practice patient, happened to need treatment when Richards was away and so became Godfrey’s responsibility by chance. Florey took to him and appointed him College Doctor to Queen’s in early 1966 – a very controversial appointment, because in the sixties College Doctors were usually elderly senior partners in local practices. In an uncharacteristically cynical moment Godfrey said in 2014 that then ‘most College Doctors were more interested in having dining rights in the colleges than looking after students’. 

Godfrey was also effectively Balliol’s College Doctor from the mid-sixties, although the appointment was not made official until Alan Richards retired in 1974. Over the years Godfrey became College Doctor to many other colleges, including St John’s and Univ, his undergraduate college, for which he had lifelong affection. 

In those days student health provision in Oxford, which was entirely organised by the colleges, was patchy and generally inadequate. Along with what he called a ‘gang of students’, Godfrey campaigned for the creation of a central medical centre and gathered supporting information by visiting several major universities, including Harvard, to study their arrangements. Lord Bulloch, the Vice Chancellor, called him in to discuss the proposal, and became a strong ally, but it came to nothing, because it was resisted by the colleges. It did, however, stimulate them to do better, for example by improving arrangements for College Nurses. And it was agreed that there was a need for central provision for student mental health, because of concern at the number of student suicides. As a direct result the University Student Counselling Service was set up in 1972. It is now an important central support system with a dozen full-time professional counsellors and is used by around 3,000 students every year. 

Godfrey was quietly proud of that result of his campaigning. But he was much more than a reforming College Doctor. He was also working as a traditional GP doing home visits, looking after families (including my own), delivering babies and developing close relationships with the patients on his list. Looking back in 2014 he said that he had found this the most satisfying part of his life’s work. 

By the early seventies he was well known as a leading GP. Sir Richard Doll, the Regius Professor of Medicine, asked him to help make a case for a University appointment in General Practice, and gave him the daunting task of presenting the case in person to the Clinical Medicine Board. When he stood up to speak, an academic snob on the Board said, ‘Come on, Godfrey, we all know you are a good GP, but don’t try to persuade us that there is anything academic about general practice.’ Nevertheless the University created the half time post of Clinical Reader in General Practice. It had to be half-time so that the incumbent could have the credibility of being in actual practice. When the post was advertised it attracted many applications, but Godfrey was happily settled as senior partner at 19 Beaumont Street, and did not apply until Doll pressed him to do so. He was appointed and took up the post in 1978. There was no automatic college attachment, but the new Reader was entitled to be taken in by a college somewhere, and we moved swiftly to secure him for Balliol. 

As Reader at first he was mostly engaged with teaching and organising a programme of placements for medical students, who were spread over around 70 general practices in Oxfordshire. But he soon established a small research group which grew, and during the next 20 years he published widely on general practice and preventative medicine. His work on helping smokers to stop smoking with nicotine replacements is especially notable. He also served on many influential national health committees. His 1989 OBE, ‘for services to medicine’, was well deserved and the citation understated. 

What he set up as Reader in 1978 has evolved by degrees into the Nuffield Department of Primary Health Care Sciences, which is the UK’s top-ranked and largest centre for academic primary health care, with over 500 staff and students, nearly 10,000 publications to its credit and 200 associated general practices. 

The University responded to the success of Godfrey’s work by making his post full-time in 1991, and recognised his distinction in 1996 by conferring the title of Professor on him. A brief but nice and informative obituary by Jake Piper which appeared in the Guardian on 21 April 2022 gives some details of Godfrey’s life and achievements which complement what I have said and has a good photograph. 

Godfrey met Sissel Vidnes in Oxford and married her in Oslo in September 1962. They were blessed with a happy family life, and Godfrey was proud of their sons Jeremy and Adrian, and Jeremy’s son Matthew. But in 1995 they had the desperate sadness of losing Adrian following an accident at Oxford station. 

Norway became very much part of Godfrey’s life. Sissel’s parents had a skiing hut near Oslo which Godfrey and Sissel used most Easters for a week or so, skiing every day. The photograph reproduced here was taken by Oslofjord. Later they bought a flat with a view of the fjord and they went there several times a year after Godfrey retired in 1997, often taking Matthew with them. Between these frequent visits to Norway Godfrey participated actively in Balliol life as an Emeritus Fellow and enjoyed the excursions of the walking group which he founded with his friend Sir Roger Bannister and others. 

In the last couple of years his mobility and short-term memory declined, but when I visited him ten days before he died he chatted cheerfully about old times, and he gave me a firm handshake after walking me to the door. 

He told me more than once how profoundly grateful he was to Sissel for her care in his old age. He was a kind, patient, modest man of principle who had a productive valuable life. We must all give thanks for that and be grateful that in the end he did not linger. 

The funeral service was held in Balliol Chapel, 25 April 2022, conducted by Revd Canon Bruce Kinsey (Chaplain) and Revd Professor Judith Brown (Emeritus Fellow).

Professor Roger Lonsdale FRSL FBA

Andrew Bradley Junior Research Fellow 1960–1963, Tutorial Fellow in English 1963–2000, Vice-Master 1978–1980 and Emeritus Fellow from 2000
06 August 1934 — 28 February 2022

Professor Seamus Perry (Professor of English Literature, Massey Fellow, Tutor in English and Fellow Librarian) 

Roger LonsdaleRoger Harrison Lonsdale was born in Hornsea on the Yorkshire coast on 6 August 1934 and attended Hymers School in nearby Hull. He was not only a good scholar but also a good citizen, serving as editor of the school magazine (1950–1952), as well as Secretary of the Music and Debating Societies and Under Officer of the Combined Cadet Force. He was made Head of House and played in the First XI, so when he left in 1952 he could scarcely have had a more glittering track record. Talking with him once about the business of undergraduate admissions, I remember Roger telling me that he had first put in to read English at Christ Church: there he was interviewed by the formidable J.I.M. Stewart, who turned him down. (‘So you see’, Roger said with the barest shadow of a smile, ‘no one always gets it right.’) He tried again and was more successful with Lincoln College. Young men were usually advised to do their National Service before coming up, and Roger did his two years as a Navigator in the Royal Air Force before arriving at Lincoln in 1954. 

His tutor was Wallace Robson, a young and gifted member of the Faculty who enjoyed a mild notoriety among the old guard for publicly admiring the Cambridge critic F.R. Leavis. Robson was an effective (if, by report, rather disorganised) tutor who inspired great affection in his pupils, but the important influence on Roger lay elsewhere. Robson (as I remember Roger telling the story) had a term’s leave at one point, so Lonsdale was farmed out to F.W. Bateson, the English tutor at Corpus; and when Robson returned from his sabbatical Roger told him that he would rather prefer to stay with Bateson. That sounds like a very assured, even audacious, gesture for a young man to make; but Bateson and Robson were on very good terms and the change of tutor, as Roger described it, does not seem to have been awkward: Bateson, indeed, was the figure to whom bright and rising members of the Faculty such as Robson looked up. Bateson must have been an exciting figure for an ambitious young scholar in many ways: besides his great personal gifts as a teacher, he was famous for the Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature (1941), an immense work in four volumes that undertook to cover the whole of English literary history from the Anglo-Saxons to the year 1900; he had just founded a new journal, Essays in Criticism; and he would shortly go on to launch, as general editor, the Annotated English Poets series for Longman, the first concerted attempt to produce textually authoritative editions of the major English poets with full explanatory notes. Leavis was a gifted critic and Oxford was full of weighty scholarship, both excellent things; but Bateson inspired a gifted generation of pupils by advocating a combination of the two, marrying critical dexterity and scholarly heft; and Roger clearly took the example to heart.

He took a First in 1957 and began his doctorate on 18th-century literature. In pursuit of that he Fellow of Balliol, 1960s. spent two years in Yale University where he worked with James Osborn, a vivid character and a remarkable collector with a perpetual post at Yale as ‘Research Associate’: he had done his BLitt in Oxford in the thirties and was a friend of Bateson’s. Roger’s return to Oxford marked the beginning of his long association with Balliol: he was elected Andrew Bradley Junior Research Fellow in 1960, completing his DPhil in 1962 with a thesis about Charles Burney (1726–1814) which went on to form the basis of his first book, Charles Burney: A Literary Biography (1965). Charles Burney was an historian of music and himself a distinguished musician and composer, as well as a man of letters, and so spoke to two of Roger’s most passionate interests: for his love of music was profound, though sometimes articulated in characteristically rueful ways. When I coincided him with once at lunch he was regretting the terrible disruption that would shortly be caused to life by his catching the train to London that afternoon. I gathered that he was going to the latest in a complete sequence of the symphonies of Shostakovich at the Royal Festival Hall, and that he had signed up for all 15. My face must have betrayed some surprise at his making such an audacious commitment because he went on to explain vaguely: ‘I thought I ought to.’ He was obviously looking forward to it enormously. 

He became Tutorial Fellow in 1963, a post he would retain until 2000. Shortly after his election to Balliol he married Anne Mary Menzies, with whom he had a son and a daughter. The marriage was later dissolved; and, in 1999, he re married, his spouse then a Research Fellow of the College, Nicoletta (Nico) Momigliano (1993), now a Professor of Aegean Studies at Bristol University.

In College he served his turn as Vice-Master (1978–1980) and Senior Fellow (1994–2000); in the University he held a British Academy Readership in 1982 1984 before being elected to a Readership in the University in 1990 and to a personal Chair in 1992. He was made a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature in 1990, and of the British Academy in 1991. 

As such honours imply, his career was immensely distinguished: he is among the very greatest literary scholars in the history of the Oxford Faculty. Bateson signed him up for a volume in his Longman series and the result was an edition of Gray, Collins, and Goldsmith (1969) which remains unsurpassed half a century later: in both textual deliberation and critical commentary it is an exemplary performance. Some of the notes are effectively essays: of the line in Gray’s ‘Elegy’, ‘The ploughman homeward plods his weary way’, for example, Roger has what amounts to a miniature dissertation summarising the unlikely controversy that the line prompted in the pages of the Gentleman’s Magazine about ‘the timetable of the English ploughman’, as well as adducing pretexts for it in Virgil and Horace, Ambrose Philips and John Gay, Joseph Warton and Edmund Spenser. The learning is massive, but the tone always light and easy and, for want of a better word, companionable. He thought it would be improper, he said, for his notes to occupy an entire page and successfully persuaded the typesetters to arrange things so that when that state of affairs threatened, at least one line of poetry would sit on top of the densely printed column of erudition of which it was the occasion. His other great scholarly achievement was an extraordinary edition of Johnson’s Lives of the Poets in four weighty volumes for Oxford University Press (2006): it took him many years to bring to completion and was instantly recognised as the masterpiece it is. ‘It is hard to find words of sufficient praise for it’, said Henry Woudhuysen, ‘this is a great and classic edition’; ‘quite simply a marvelous scholarly performance’, said Frank Kermode. It quickly won prizes, including the Modern Language Association Prize for a Distinguished Scholarly Edition. 

Besides these, other, more anthological, forms of editing occupied him, making him a well-known fixture in the Bodleian Upper Reading Room as he worked through a whole century of English poetry: the results, the New Oxford Book of Eighteenth Century Verse (1984) and Eighteenth Century Women Poets: An Oxford Anthology (1989), between them redefined the sense of an entire literary epoch. What John Carey (Andrew Bradley Junior Research Fellow 1959–1960 and Honorary Fellow) said about the Oxford Book was no less true of its sequel: ‘enthralling’ and enforcing ‘a reappraisal of what eighteenth century poetry is’. Among Roger’s other works were an edition of Beckford’s orientalist extravaganza Vathek (1970) and The Poems of John Bampfylde (1988), which rescued from almost complete neglect a highly distinctive, tragic voice from the late 18th century. Such editorial work engaged most of Roger’s academic life, but the gift for vivid biography demonstrated in the early study of Burney re-appeared from time to time – in the wonderful account of Joel Collier, ‘that remarkable musical traveller, buffoon, bassoonist, castrato, and Methodist convert’, which he contributed to the volume in Osborn’s memory (1979), for example, and in the touching biographical sketch that prefaces his edition of Bampfylde, He was also an accomplished literary critic: he contributed a masterly essay on Pope’s ambivalence to the Augustan volume of the Sphere History of Literature (1971) of which he was also the editor; and his account of Thomas Gray, first delivered as Chatterton Lecture to the British Academy (1973), remains one of the best things ever written about the elusive genius of that strange poet. And as you could tell from his conversation, he habitually brought his critical discrimination to bear on the whole range of literature: one story told at his memorial service in Balliol Chapel was about his decision to re-read Anthony Powell’s Dance to the Music of Time to see if it was as bad as he remembered it. It was. 

After his retirement he remained a much-loved member of the Common Room and a wry, discerning observer of the Oxford scene, often to be found at coffee with John Burrow (who adored him) exchanging reminiscences and observations. In 2003 I was elected to the Massey Fellowship which he had occupied with such distinction for so long, and for a year or two I had the experience of being stopped by members of the College with the peculiarly Oxonian enquiry about succession: ‘So, you’re Roger?’ I wish. Roger himself could not have been kinder, though it wouldn’t have crossed his mind to hand down anything as pompous as sage advice. I once asked him whether he thought an editor should modernise a text or keep it in original spelling: ‘Oh well,’ he said, ‘I could argue that both ways.’ One tip I do remember him giving me was that from time to time a student will opt to write on an author about whom you know really very little: the thing to do in those circumstances, he said, is simply to listen to the essay and thank the student for teaching you something new. At which point a slightly melancholy look crossed his face: ‘Of course, you can’t do that every week.’ He was a man of great modesty and kindliness and he possessed an innate scholarly humility. I once told him how much I admired a recent book about Alexander Pope, about whom of course he was profoundly expert: Roger warmly agreed before adding, ‘but it is very deep and I’m not sure I’ve got to the bottom of it.’ Everything he said was graced with a wonderfully dry, self-directed humour that belied the quite unrivalled authority of his learning. His immense scholarly generosity was valued by innumerable students of the subject and his loss will be lamented by very many friends and admirers across the globe; but they will take some solace in the knowledge that his work will continue to shape our understanding of 18th-century literature for years to come.

A Tribute 

Sir Christopher Ricks (Andrew Bradley Junior Research Fellow 1957 and Honorary Fellow) 

Roger in his twenties (he and I, in our twenties, at Oxford): a heartening difficulty attends upon summoning the young Roger. For although the then Roger proves of course distinguishable – even at this distance – from any later Roger, they could never be in any way distinct. In every respect Roger was at one. During the time he did in New Haven, he set down his sense of an evening with an old friend: ‘I must say that he seems a rather different person from the one I remembered.’ This is an authentic reluctance (I must say . . .). But no one ever said to herself or himself, of Roger, I must say that he seems a rather different person from the one I remembered. The enduring truth is most endearing: his exquisite diffidence was always the same. Few things are ever simple, but in this, as in so much else, Roger was simply lovely. 

His personal being always enjoyed continuity with his professional doings, whether as a great scholar or teacher. And he was never loud-spoken or hard spoken (there is more than one opposite of soft). When Alfred Tennyson welcomed into the family the man who was becoming his brother-in-law, the poet understood what it is to be ‘worthy’ by calling upon the word ‘consistent’, standing well together:

worthy; full of power; 
As gentle; liberal-minded, great, 
Consistent; wearing all that weight 
Of learning lightly like a flower.
 

– even as Roger wore lightly all his weight of learning. 

Continuity, consistent, concurring, constituting his self: the preferred prepositional prefix was con-. (Never contra-.) 

And preferred pronouns? we, us, and this without the tricks that we and us can get up to, nothing of the royal We or the editorial We or the schizophrenic We. Nothing of what – as long ago as 1797 – got dubbed wegotism (‘an obtrusive and too frequent use of the first person plural by a speaker or writer’). Straightforward and humane: you and I, along with you and me. 

From the age of 14 to 24, 1948 to 1959, Roger was a poet. His poet was Philip Larkin, as he himself put it: ‘I can still remember reading “No Road” and other poems in The Less Deceived (1955) for the first time, and realising that this was exactly how I would have liked to write myself if I could. If in some ways my poems were the better for his influence, in the end my intense admiration for him would silence me as a poet (especially after my tutor F.W. Bateson, mischievously no doubt, described me to my face as “the poor man’s Larkin”, which was a bit cruel).’ Perfectly Roger, the temperate wording, ‘a bit cruel’. The historian Frederick Foakes Jackson, of Jesus College, Cambridge, advised a newly elected young don: ‘It’s no use trying to be clever – we are all clever here; just try to be kind – a little kind.’ Such is the right consideration. 

Considerations 

from Oxford Poetry (1958) 

Considering that a season now has passed 
Since I deliberately grieved to lose 
To the night you – at last, 
But then too late, resolved to please 
In a new dress, turning slowly past
The wise deploring self I chose;

Considering that I left you, walked an hour, 
Met friends and was at ease, 
I do not see Why absence need recur, 
And be disturbing tirelessly 
My later inclinations, leaving sour 
Each new affection granted me.

For I would not complain seven months are gone 
Proper to thoughts of you; but that what’s over A new dress or an old fashion 
Failing to please – must leave me never 
Considering again a season is my own 
Or safe with any self or lover.

And, from New Haven, the next year, 1959: 

Song 

Learn, lover, to withstand
The violent imprecision
Of lover turning friend:
Better that love should end
With sharp derision, 
 

Than haunt old rooms to find – 
To pack and unpack more 
What must be left behind. 
Avoid her eyes, and stand 
Impatient at the door.
 

Such poems, like all of Roger’s works and days, make clear that a relaxed intelligence is no relaxing of intelligence. ‘Be watchful, and strengthen the things which remain, that are ready to die.’ The Book of Revelation, with then T.S. Eliot and For Lancelot Andrewes: Essays on Style and Order: ‘Set in order the things which are wanting among us, and strengthen those which remain, and are ready to die.’ To set a crown upon his lifetime’s effort, there appeared in 2006 Roger’s incomparable edition of Samuel Johnson, The Lives of the Most Eminent English Poets; with Critical Observations on Their Works. The responsibilities of an editor, responsibilities so thoroughly realised by Roger, had been authoritatively set down by Housman: ‘To read attentively, think correctly, omit no relevant consideration, and repress self-will, are not ordinary accomplishments; yet an emendator [indeed, any editor] needs much besides: just literary perception, congenial intimacy with the author, experience which must have been won by study, and mother wit which he must have brought from his mother’s womb.’ 

There just happens to have been a further womb. Roger reported in 1963 the birth in Oxford of ‘the new Ricks baby’: ‘while it was being born I was called in to look after the other three – David, Julia, and Laura – for two hours, with the baby being born overhead. They were the two most harrassing hours of my life!’ 

Dear Roger, you must not call a baby it (you must of course call it they). Meanwhile, sorry about – and for ever grateful for – the two hours, the two most harassing hours of your life, so harassing as to fret you into spelling the word with two r’s. 

The baby, William, is now 59, Laura 60, Julia 62, and David (‘my husband’, says Katy) is now 63. Roger is ageless, a dearest of old friends. 

The address above was spoken at Roger Lonsdale’s memorial service in Balliol Chapel on 4 June 2022 by Katy Ricks (1979), who prefaced it with the following words: 

A characteristic editorial touch from Christopher was to suggest, for the order of service in your hand, ‘spoken by’, rather than’ read by’. I speak his words in double trust – for the Ricks family, as Christopher’s daughter-in-law, and for Balliol, as one of Roger’s former students. 

Roger told me years after the event that I had been the first woman undergraduate he interviewed. By interview he meant sit on a bench in the Quad, in summer 1978, talking about Keats. A mark of the great teacher Roger was, is that I realised only as I was thinking of these few words of introduction, that I remember exactly what he asked me about ‘The Eve of St Agnes’, and exactly what thoughts he elicited from his newest recruit. Roger said later, ‘And do you know, I thought this is going to be rather fun.’ Roger was the first Oxford don I had ever met, and my thoughts on fun rather concurred. So, I have Balliol, and because of Balliol, David Ricks, to be grateful to Roger for. 

Another Ricks woman, the two-year old Julia, never too young for buttering up a dashing don, took a great shine to Roger, insisting on buttering his toast, at every opportunity. 

Poems reproduced by kind permission of Nicoletta Momigliano.