Professor Frances Stewart (Professor Emeritus of Development Economics, Somerville College)
In 2008, William Barber (1949) dedicated his book about Gunnar Myrdal ‘To Paul Streeten: Inspiring teacher, distinguished scholar and valued friend’. These words beautifully summarise the life of Paul Streeten, who died in January 2019, aged 101.
His qualities were apparent from an early stage. In 1944, the Principal and Vice-Chancellor of Aberdeen University (Sir William Fyfe), recommending him to Balliol, wrote that he was ‘a human of the prime class’, both ‘clever and charming’ (letters from Fyfe to Master of Balliol, 16 April 1944 and 7 October 1944); while his Balliol tutor, Thomas Balogh, in a letter to the Rockefeller Foundation in 1947, said: ‘he has a brilliant mind, remarkable not only for originality, but also for a firm grasp of the facts’ (2 January 1947).
Paul was born in Austria, son of Wilhelm and Berta Hornig. His father died when he was only two, and he was brought up by his mother and her family. As a teenager in Vienna in the 1930s, Paul devoted himself to the socialist youth movement, marching, demonstrating, and, after 1933, participating in underground activities, including carrying messages and distributing illegal news-sheets. But in the mid-1930s his interests switched from the youth movement to intellectual pursuits, including psychology and sociology, influenced, among others, by Max Adler, who was a family friend (as were Wittgenstein and Freud). Paul’s political perspective also changed: from a belief in revolutionary socialism towards social democratic views; and, as he states in a personal memoir, from a preoccupation with public life and politics towards more private, individual concerns (Streeten 1986). He retained the later perspectives throughout the rest of his life: an intellectual, a man of progressive values, not a political activist.
The Hornig family were secular Jews; they managed to flee after the Anschluss, his mother and brother to the US, his aunt’s family to Palestine, and Paul himself to the UK, where he lived, for a short time with two sisters, called Streeten. Soon after arriving in England, he was admitted to read Economics at Aberdeen University (they did not have a department for sociology, his preferred subject), but after a year there he was interned as an ‘enemy alien’, in unpleasant conditions – first in the Isle of Man and then Canada. Eventually, he was released, returned to the UK and joined a Commando Unit to be dropped into Sicily in advance of the main invasion. When he joined the unit he was told to change his name from Hornig in case he was captured, and he chose the name ‘Streeten’. The sisters were apparently delighted. He was very badly wounded in Italy, and spent a year in hospital.
He was then admitted to Balliol to read PPE. When he arrived in November 1944 his arm was still strapped up. In Balliol, his economics tutors were Maurice Allen (Fellow and Tutor in Economics 1931–1948) and Thomas Balogh (Fellow and Tutor in Economics 1945–1973), the latter in particular becoming a lifelong friend and collaborator. Paul found the combination of the two an excellent one: while Maurice Allen taught the basics of economics with clarity and logic, Tommy Balogh ‘was so confusing that I had to go back to my room and work it out for myself’ (Streeten 1986). After getting a first in PPE, Paul was made a lecturer in Balliol, substituting for Maurice Allen, who had joined the Bank of England, and when Maurice left permanently, Paul became official Fellow and Tutor in Economics.
Paul was a brilliant tutor – I myself was taught economics by him as an undergraduate, from 1959 to 1961, and later he supervised my doctorate. He listened carefully and with respect, gave incisive comments, and made every topic interesting. He treated one as an equal, as a respected colleague rather than an ignorant student. Other accounts1 of his teaching agree:
Paul combined an incisive intellect and an original mind with a striking lucidity
in speaking and writing, which made him a superb teacher – Professor Deepak
Nayyar (1967 and Honorary Fellow)
. . . a guru in the full sense of the term that folds teacher, guide and inspirer into
one – Professor Akbar Noman (1966)
You [Paul] had the remarkable, indeed unique gift of listening and discussing
with a young student as if with an equal, as if (could it have been true?) what the
student was saying really interested you. – Steven Lukes (1958)
Three economists had a particularly important influence over Paul’s thinking and writing. Maurice Allen’s rigour and sharp logic can be seen in the very careful analytic papers Paul wrote in the late 1940s and 1950s – for example, his paper on ‘The Theory of Profit’ (Streeten 1949), ‘The Effect of Taxation on Risk-taking’ (Streeten 1953), ‘Reserve Capacity and the Kinked Demand Curve’ (Streeten 1950-51), among many. Papers he wrote at this time present carefully argued critiques of conventional views, particularly questioning their underlying assumptions about human behaviour and economic relationships and coming to controversial conclusions. For example, he suggested that higher profits taxation might not reduce risk-taking but could increase it, with different assumptions about behaviour and technology. These papers, taken together, provide a devastating critique of prevalent micro-economic assumptions and conclusions, showing that they are based on a simplistic view of economic relationships. What these, and later, papers underline is that the world is too complex to be described and analysed in simple economic models, yet, as Paul later acknowledged, ‘it takes a model to kick out a model’ (quoted in Stretton 1986: 8). This partially explains the persistence of the models in mainstream economics.
A second major influence on Paul’s thought and life was Thomas Balogh, an iconoclast with an instinctive distrust of conventional thinking and, quite often, brilliant insights, yet lacking careful analytic analysis to back these insights. A succession of papers written jointly with Balogh marry Balogh’s iconoclasm with Paul’s sharp, critical and systematic analysis to produce some important and influential contributions. Perhaps the best of these is ‘The Coefficient of Ignorance’ (Balogh and Streeten 1963), which provides a devastating critique of the widely accepted and extremely influential growth model of Solow, arguing that it leaves a huge ‘black box’ of unexplained growth, which Solow attributes to (unexplained) ‘technical progress’, and Balogh and Streeten rightly term ‘the coefficient of ignorance’.
The third economist to have a considerable influence over Paul’s approach to economics was the Swedish Nobel Prize winner Gunnar Myrdal. In addition to being an academic economist, Myrdal was a political activist in Sweden in the 1930s, partly responsible for the introduction of a welfare state. His major early contribution was to question the role of values in economics – economists then and now2 generally assume that their analytic and positive work is value free, and that values enter only in normative statements – which theorists try to avoid. Myrdal’s first important publication on this was The Political Element in the Development of Economic Theory, published in Swedish in 1930 and translated into German in 1932. Paul met Myrdal in the late 1940s and agreed to translate the book from German to English. The English version came out in 1953 with an appendix on ‘Recent Controversies’ by Paul illustrating how economists continued to ignore the political element.
The need to untangle the manifold ways that values penetrated economic theory was an important component of Paul’s work. He attacked the view that ethical judgements had no place in scientific analysis, arguing that values informed assumptions and concepts in complex and pervasive ways. Perhaps the best illustration of this was in his penetrating paper on ‘Economics and Value Judgements’ (Streeten 1950). This paper went beyond the ‘political element’, showing how the penetration of values into economics was so central that it was not possible to deal with the issue, as Myrdal had recommended, simply by being explicit about the values of the analyst. Many concepts ‘both describe facts and contain valuations’ (Streeten 1950: 584). This view was later adopted by Myrdal in Value in Social Theory (Myrdal 1958, Myrdal 1968), a collection of papers, put together and translated by Paul, which contains a critique of welfare economics by Paul – ‘Programmes and Prognoses’ – which, among other things, attacks the separation of means and ends that is assumed in much social welfare theory.
In the early 1960s the direction of Paul’s work changed from preoccupation with economic theory to the broader arena of development economics and it is in this field that his formidable global reputation lies. Several events led to this switch. First, Myrdal invited him to work on his mammoth book Asian Drama (Myrdal 1968), to which Paul contributed an important appendix, entitled ‘Economic Models and Their Usefulness for Planning in South Asia’, which contains a thorough critique of the assumption of a constant capital output ratio that, at the time, formed a fundamental component of planning for economic growth. In 1963 he was invited to work on problems of Indian planning at the Indian Statistical Institute in Delhi. In 1964, he became Deputy Director General of the just established Ministry of Overseas Development. From 1966, Paul was Deputy Director (and Acting Director) of the newly founded Institute of Development Studies at Sussex University, and in 1968 he became Warden of Queen Elizabeth House and Director of the Institute of Commonwealth Studies at Oxford. He joined the World Bank in 1978 to work with the Pakistani economist Mahbub ul Haq, and subsequently moved to Boston University as Director of the Economics Department’s Center for Asian Development Studies, which later became the World Development Institute. This, his final appointment, was a fitting post for Paul, who was a citizen of the world, not only in terms of his personal geographical trajectory – which encompassed many countries from every region of the world – but also his far-reaching interests and contributions.
Paul worked on development economics issues for half a century, producing a huge stream of papers and books. Although the topics changed, his approach remained informed by his early work, including a continued preoccupation with values, a questioning of conventional concepts and models, particularly the unthinking transfer of Western concepts to the different situation of developing countries, and a critique of a strict means/ ends distinction. The hallmark of a Streeten paper is a precise deconstruction of concepts and theory, and suggestions for a range of alternative approaches. Every paper was written with style, wit and subtlety. The papers were the writings of a PPE product, combining all three disciplines. He is often described as an ‘institutionalist’ (for example by Stretton, 1986), meaning that to understand development one must understand the institutions in place in the particular context, encompassing both formal and informal structures, human motivation and behaviour, institutions which are frequently ignored in mainstream analysis. But no one categorisation does him justice, and were he around he would undoubtedly find several compelling reasons why this appellation is incorrect.
Perhaps his best-known contribution in development was his work on Basic Needs: that is the idea that a predominant objective of development should be to see that every person’s basic needs are met – for food, shelter, education, and non-material needs such as employment and dignity; and that this objective should be given priority over the maximisation of economic growth. Together with Mahbub ul Haq he convinced the head of the World Bank to make Basic Needs a priority, in the late 1970s, and he led a team in the World Bank to analyse the implications. The work was brought together in (Streeten, Burki et al. 1981). For a short while, until the debt crisis and the dominance of neo-liberal economics swamped poverty-focused strategies, the Basic Needs approach was propagated by the World Bank in its dealings with developing countries. Despite the economic crisis of the 1980s, these ideas did not go away, but reappeared in a different and more sophisticated format, in the Human Development approach, elaborated in the 1990 Human Development Report to which Paul contributed.
Other important contributions included:
• a critique of the idea of balanced growth in which he provided convincing reasons why unbalanced growth might be more productive than balanced growth as bottlenecks may create incentives and opportunities;
• a critique of the use of Western concepts of employment and unemployment applied in a developing country context, and similarly of the capital-output ratio, as noted above;
• analysis of the role of foreign investment in development, giving it neither wholesale condemnation, as many did, nor wholesale praise as others did, but carefully differentiating good and bad characteristics in varying circumstances;
• analysis of how economists can contribute to (and qualify) Economic and Social Rights;
• continued contributions to successive Human Development Reports, including putting the concept of ‘jobless growth’ on the map; in this area his repeated insistence that a strict means/end distinction is invalid was particularly pertinent.
work consisted in analysing, classifying and deconstructing accepted views. As he himself said, ‘I have always been better as a critic than as an apologist or propagator or advocate’ (Streeten 1986: 154). Yet even though it takes models to push out models, the cumulative effect of the work of Paul and others (including Myrdal, Seers, Hirschman and many of Paul’s students) has been to lead to a general acceptance of the need for multidisciplinarity in development analysis, to take context into account, to widen development objectives beyond economic growth and to be cautious before making unthinking use of conventional concepts and theories.
Apart from intellectual contributions, Paul also made substantial institutional ones, as a good ‘institutionalist’ should. He turned Queen Elizabeth House into a thriving multidisciplinary centre of teaching and research, reflecting his own wide-ranging perspectives. During his wardenship, Queen Elizabeth House became a haven for visitors from overseas – in particular welcoming Visiting Fellows from the subcontinent and a succession of intellectual refugees, especially from Bangladesh, when their home environment became hostile. In 1972, he started World Development, and was the chief editor for many decades, turning it into the pre-eminent multidisciplinary development journal. The journal reflected Paul’s approach, both in its multidisciplinarity and in its catholic and tolerant reach, welcoming papers from the orthodox as well as the heterodox.
For those who knew Paul, he will be remembered not just as a scholar but also as a witty, stimulating and gentle friend, with dancing eyes, always ready for a gossip, ‘a verray parfit gentil knight’, as Hugh Stretton wrote in concluding a biographical essay.
Paul had a very long (67 years) happy marriage to Anne. He leaves two daughters (Tish and Judy), a stepson (Jay), two granddaughters (Emma and Tulsi) and two great-grandchildren (Leo and Siena).
Paul was devoted to Balliol. Replying to the letter telling him he had been awarded an Honorary Fellowship, he wrote: ‘Balliol is my second family and to be honoured by Balliol is the most wonderful thing that can happen’ (letter to the Master, 5 March 1986).
1 Tributes to Paul on his 100th birthday.
2 Myrdal commented when a new edition of his book was being produced in 1982: ‘This book is unfortunately as much to the point today as when it was first published.’ (Swedburg 1990)
References
Balogh, T. and P.P. Streeten (1963). ‘The Coefficient of Ignorance.’ Bulletin of the Oxford University Institute of Economics & Statistics 25(2): 99–107.
Myrdal, G. (1958). Value in Social Theory: A Selection of Essays on Methodology. London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
Myrdal, G. (1968). Asian Drama: An Inquiry into the Poverty of Nations. London, Allen Lane, The Penguin Press.
Streeten, P. (1949). ‘The Theory of Profit.’ Manchester School XVII(3): 266–296.
Streeten, P. (1950). ‘Economics and Value Judgements.’ Quarterly Journal of Economics 64(4): 583–595.
Streeten, P. (1950–51). ‘Reserve Capacity and the Kinked Demand Curve’. Review of Economic Studies 18(2): 103–113.
Streeten, P. (1953). ‘The Effect of Taxation on Risk-taking.’ Oxford Economic Papers 7(3): 271–287.
Streeten, P. (1986). ‘Aerial Roots.’ Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review 157: 135–159.
Streeten, P.P., S.J. Burki, M. ul Haq, N. Hicks and F. Stewart (1981). First Things First: Meeting Basic Human
Needs in Developing Countries. New York, OUP.
Stretton, H. (1986). Paul Streeten: An Appreciation. Theory and Reality in Development. S. Lall and F. Stewart. London, Macmillan: 1–27.
Swedburg, R. (1990). Introduction to The Political Element in the Development of Economic Theory. R. Swedberg. London, Transaction Publishers: vii–xxxvii.
I am grateful for some comments on a previous draft from Deepak Nayyar (1967) and Akbar Noman (1966), both former students of Paul.