‘Were the Disciples Mad?’

24 October 2019, 5.15pm
Balliol Chapel

Dr David Foreman of King’s College London and Dr Alexandru Popescu (Balliol 1994) will give an interdisciplinary seminar entitled: ‘Were the Disciples Mad? A Dialectical Debate on the Relationship between Religion, Meaning, and Mental Health’. Dr Alexandru Popescu will speak on ‘Faith and Health’ and Dr David Foreman on ‘Erroneous Subjectivity and Religious Experiences’.

Abstract: ‘Health’ and ‘Mental Health’ are described by the Constitution of World Health Organisation (1948) in secular terms, with no explicit reference to their spiritual dimension. Clinical psychiatry remains grounded in phenomenology. The major classes of psychiatric disorder — schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, depression, and anxiety — are all diagnosed by a mixture of beliefs, sensory or emotional states that appear to have no connection with either the sensorium or circumstances. However, religious experiences also include perceptions without visible correlates, deeply held convictions of truths that have no objective evidence and appear logically incoherent, and profound swings of emotion which cannot be explained in terms of relationships or life experiences. There is, therefore, an unanswered question about how these states should be valued, distinguished, and situated in our social world. Starting from an interdisciplinary re-evaluation of health from its spiritual and sentient dimensions, we shall attempt to address this question from the perspective of recent advances in our understanding of mental health and brain function. 

Guest speaker Revd James Ramsay, formerly Chaplain at the University of East London, will offer a reflection on his own near-death experience in Intensive Care.

Dr David Foreman is a Child and Adolescent Psychiatrist, currently interested in Public Mental Health. As a Fellow of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, he was a founding member of its Philosophy Special Interest Group. He is also responsible for liaison between the Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Perinatal Faculty Executives.

Dr Alexandru Popescu is a Pastoral Associate of Balliol Chapel. He was a Research Fellow at UCLA and UTAS and Chair of the ‘Theology and Mental Health’ Sub-Committee, ‘Faith Communities and Mental Health’ Reference Group, World Council of Churches. His research interests include the nosology of autism spectrum disorders, the psychology of the Gulag, and the psychiatry of totalitarianism.

There is a podcast of this event here.